Re:Oroville Dam: Cost to repair spillways nearly doubles in ...
by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 21, 2017 @11:17PM
(#15524996)
I will make no attempt to defend the specific recommendations I mooted. There is better work, in any case, in the academic domain on fixing our flawed civil-engineering auction processes.
The problems anyone campaigning for auction reform runs into are three-fold. One, it's a boring problem with boring solutions. Two, there are vested interests. And three, Americans suffer from a just-world bias when it comes to infrastructure [1]. The latter is apparent even in this thread. It's difficult to find solutions when people vigorously defend a clearly-flawed system.
Re:Oroville Dam: Cost to repair spillways nearly doubles in ...
by yrb on Sunday October 22, 2017 @12:06AM
(#15525109)
For sure. I don't know how you overcome the inertia of our societies structure to head towards something that would likely be better for the majority of citizens. Which is a problem in many more domains that just civil works auctions.
I can see how the recommendation you mooted would improve incentives in some procurement domains. Large civil works isn't one of them however.
I just don't think your incentives would produce better outcomes, from my perspective it would make things worse.