Re:Q&A: Douglas Hofstadter on why AI is far from intelligent
by mindcrime on Saturday October 21, 2017 @10:59PM
(#15524934)
Strong, general AI will be its own species, with its own unique way of thinking and its own quirks. Trying to replicate humans exactly is futile and worthless.
Well said.
We don't need a human made of silicon for that. We need a mechanical dog.
That's a very eloquent way of putting it. I may have to steal this quote from you sometime!
Re:Q&A: Douglas Hofstadter on why AI is far from intelligent
by __s on Saturday October 21, 2017 @05:25PM
(#15523694)
Likely some fear a sufficiently intelligent AI without human like values will render human life obsolete-- and then extinct
Humans seem pretty good at enacting the latter all on their lonesome
We look at a dolphin and we can say "that is an independently intelligent animal" that we can't really do much with. We look at a dog and say "that is a useful, trainable, intelligent animal" that we as humans couldn't have survived without during parts of the history of our species. A dolphin is far smarter, but it doesn't matter because there's only one intelligent animal we couldn't have lived without, and it's actually pretty dumb compared to a dolphin.
The question is, do we want an AI that is smart by itself, or do we want an AI that is smart and useful to us? Those don't have to be the same thing, as evidenced by the dolphin vs the dog.
Humans are really, really good at producing very efficient machines with strong intellect, we do it by accident all the time. We don't need more humans, humans are flawed and humans have a lot of undesirable traits to go along with the intelligence. Strong, general AI will be its own species, with its own unique way of thinking and its own quirks. Trying to replicate humans exactly is futile and worthless.
We want a machine that can learn and do useful stuff. We don't need a human made of silicon for that. We need a mechanical dog.