News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rust for real time audio analysis by dljsjr on Friday October 20, 2017 @05:39PM (#15519297)
From my understanding (and also mentioned by someone in the comments on the RFC I linked), while you can do things to the threads by just directly calling through to C, what you end up with is a thread that doesn't have all of the Rust runtime niceties set up on it correctly.

I'm just waiting for a full featured version of this functionality to be available in the language, but I was also sort of curious to see what OP's solution to the problem was.

And like I mentioned originally, my day job is to maintain code that does the same thing but for Java. I don't wanna have to maintain it in two languages even if one is just a pet project. Since Rust is billing itself as a systems language it makes sense that this will be a feature eventually, and I'm willing to wait patiently. It's not holding me back from anything, it's just a personal curiosity.

Re:Rust for real time audio analysis by steveklabnik on Friday October 20, 2017 @08:58PM (#15520088)
Rust doesn’t really have much of a runtime; I’m not sure what niceties you’re thinkjg of :)

(I also logged that you talked about this in the issue; even knowing people want this is useful; it’s probably not in std because nobody’s ever really argued they need it!)

Re:Rust for real time audio analysis by dljsjr on Monday October 23, 2017 @12:36PM (#15534466)
Thanks for taking the time to look at this Steve!

I'm not super familiar with threading in Rust, I was just going off comments made in the RFC and what little research I had done at the time I started looking in to it. This was all a few years ago and I know the runtime used to be much heavier so my info could very well be out of date.

I know that this is a feature that doesn't impact a large number of people, but for the people that do need it it's pretty important. Being able to do soft real-time threading inside of an RTOS environment like Xenomai or Linux w/ the preemptive kernel (RT) patch in combination with Rust's other safety-oriented features would be a huge boon for embedded developers I think.

Re:Rust for real time audio analysis by steveklabnik on Monday October 23, 2017 @01:50PM (#15535244)
Ah ha! So, looking at the issue, at that time, Rust did have a runtime, and green threads. Today, we don't, and just have OS threads. So that's where the miscommunication lies :)
Re:Rust for real time audio analysis by rapsey on Saturday October 21, 2017 @12:07AM (#15520602)
> while you can do things to the threads by just directly calling through to C, what you end up with is a thread that doesn't have all of the Rust runtime niceties set up on it correctly.

That is incorrect. Rust threads are system threads and nothing more.

> I'm just waiting for a full featured version of this functionality to be available in the language, but I was also sort of curious to see what OP's solution to the problem was.

You will be waiting for a long time. No one is in a rush for that RFC because the functionality exists in crates and through a ffi call if you need it. Rust does not have a large standard library and will never have one as large as Java/C#. This is why the crate system exists.

Re:Rust for real time audio analysis by dljsjr on Monday October 23, 2017 @12:40PM (#15534501)
>> while you can do things to the threads by just directly calling through to C, what you end up with is a thread that doesn't have all of the Rust runtime niceties set up on it correctly.

> That is incorrect. Rust threads are system threads and nothing more.

It seems that wasn't the case years ago when I originally researched this and when the RFC I linked was filed.

> You will be waiting for a long time. No one is in a rush for that RFC because the functionality exists in crates and through a ffi call if you need it. Rust does not have a large standard library and will never have one as large as Java/C#. This is why the crate system exists.

That's fine, I'm not asking for a large standard library nor am I being held back by the absence of these features. I haven't spent a lot of time with Rust but it's on my radar so I was just asking a few questions to try and gather some info. Do note, though, that if a language wants to bill itself as a systems language that these are important features to have available and well-vetted for low-level embedded software development.