News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pointer Free Programming and the Future of Nim by pjc50 on Friday October 20, 2017 @12:04PM (#15516843)
"not letting the code compile if there is any chance it might crash"; well, normally we assume correct operation for the hardware here in order to make that achievable, otherwise things could simply crash at any time. You're always vulnerable to single-event-upsets from cosmic rays or even alpha decay inside the chip packaging. Being pedantic about this in a discussion of compiler correctness is useless derailing.

"Rowhammer" over in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15515044 is perhaps the most likely problem of hardware non-correctness to worry about.

Re:Pointer Free Programming and the Future of Nim by Jach on Friday October 20, 2017 @03:15PM (#15518465)
When talking correctness (or security) I would think pedantry would be more welcome. I think you have a point on derailment if the comment I replied to had given a specific example that refused to compile anything with a chance of crashing, e.g. through guarantees of its type system, and then I come along asking about cosmic rays. But they didn't, they were vague, and I'm still left wondering of an example because even Haskell programs crash with a segfault or bus error sometimes. It's perfectly fine that it can't cover those cases but a compiler did sign off on a program with a chance of crashing, no cosmic rays involved, at best it only assures less likelihood of crashing compared to another compiler.