News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:06AM (#15508530)
What was innovative about Whatsapp?
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:14AM (#15508592)
Sending SMS over the web. May not be particularly interesting in the US, but in countries where texting is expensive, being able to do it for "free" was a godsend.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by smsm42 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:52PM (#15509493)
Wait, they invented internet messaging??? That existed since forever. Calling it "SMS" doesn't change much. Yes, they exploit the greed of cell providers as leverage, but that's a very tactical innovation (not to dismiss it, tactical innovations can be very lucrative) but nothing strategically new.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by dsacco on Thursday October 19, 2017 @02:02PM (#15510091)
> Wait, they invented internet messaging? That existed since forever...Nothing strategically new.

WhatsApp enabled low-cost internet messaging on a global scale by taking the existing messaging technology, perfecting the user interface and positioning the product correctly (i.e. text messaging instead of instant messaging).

Sure, people could have used AIM, but then they would need to collect the emails or screen names of their close friends and encourage people to use AIM with that system. WhatsApp succeeded by framing it in the context of text messaging (something you do on your phone with friends) instead of in the context of internet messaging (something you do at a computer, and less personally). Tying the messaging to something that was already familiar and ubiquitous (phone numbers) while keeping the interface essentially the same was a real innovation.

There is a tremendous amount of innovation opportunity when two situations collide: 1) a new platform of user software emerges or becomes realistically cheap, and 2) useful systems or software exists that is extremely useful, but decentralized or frustrating to use. Mobile app stores and taxis are a good example, which resulted in Uber and Lyft.

Your criticism is substantially the same as people dismissing Dropbox’s legitimate innovation because rsync already existed. If you dig deeply enough, most real innovation can be described as a kernel of something old enhanced by something that’s new. It’s more consistent to use this heuristic for identifying innovation than it is to go by whatever personally impresses you.

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by smsm42 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @02:16PM (#15510236)
> perfecting the user interface

Frankly haven't noticed any difference in UI.

> and positioning the product correctly (i.e. text messaging instead of instant messaging).

Basically framing & marketing. Yes, that's important. But not exactly a technological innovation, rather finding a right set of words to convince the users to use existing technology.

> dismissing Dropbox’s legitimate innovation because rsync already existed.

There are substantial differences between what rsync did and what Dropbox did, especially in the area of storage and automation. rsync is just a tool to get bytes from point A to point B, Dropbox solves the end-user problem. Whatsapp doesn't add much to solutions that already existed - besides using phone number as ID instead of email, there's nothing different in UI or capabilities or solutions of this service that hadn't existed for decades before.

Uber and Lyft give me things I couldn't do before - i.e., get transportation cheap on 5-minutes notice. Whatsapp just rehashes what already existed for decades with a new label on the box. It was a successful label, good for them, but that is not what we talk about when we talk about innovations, usually.

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Friday October 20, 2017 @03:27AM (#15514084)
Tying the messaging to something that was already familiar and ubiquitous (phone numbers) while keeping the interface essentially the same was a real innovation.

As the original poster of this thread, thanks, I think that's a good answer to my question. It seems a small step considering SMS, but then again I can't remember any other app doing that, and hindsight makes many things appear simple.

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by skybrian on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:24PM (#15509752)
As I understand it they also had a stronger focus on usability for first-time Internet users in many countries. For example, porting the app to many devices (not just smart phones) and using phone numbers as user identifiers instead of usernames.

I don't know if you call that tactics or strategy, but it made a difference for user growth. Users don't care who invented it, they care if they can get it to work easily.

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:50AM (#15508939)
Yes, messaging over the Internet is useful, but we had that for a long time. Whatsapp was far from the first.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by plussed_reader on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:25PM (#15509293)
For a lot of users it was their first SMS to Web interface.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:27PM (#15509777)
Right, but that's not an innovation.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by ksk on Thursday October 19, 2017 @02:16PM (#15510238)
Okay, maybe that's not YOUR definition of innovation.

I personally like this one:

http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/innovation.html

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Friday October 20, 2017 @03:19AM (#15514054)
Is there any product that wouldn't fit that definition?
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by ksk on Friday October 20, 2017 @11:59AM (#15516791)
Products that are clones of other successful products. Which is tens of millions of products. There aren't many industries with single vendors. I think the definition perfectly captures how most people think about innovation.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by KGIII on Thursday October 19, 2017 @07:56PM (#15512543)
It might not be much of an invention, but it is an innovation.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Friday October 20, 2017 @03:18AM (#15514050)
So if I make a clone of some existing product and give it to users that never used that kind of product before, I'm being innovative?
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by KGIII on Friday October 20, 2017 @01:21PM (#15517486)
Absolutely. Pushing a product to a new group of people is innovation. It's innovation in the business aspect, not innovative on the tech side.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by rhizome on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:02PM (#15509058)
Is that quantitatively different than AIM, YahooIM, ICQ, etc.?
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by sfifs on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:25PM (#15509290)
These simply didn't have market penetration and network effects in the Indias and Indonesias of the world. Probably did not have a dominant network even in the US. Maybe they we a bit ahead of their time of easy internet availability anytime.

The other innovation was WhatsApp used phone numbers already stored on phone address book as identifiers, allowing rapid user onboarding and spread without much effort by the user. Again maybe these others happened before the smartphone revolution making this possible

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by praneshp on Thursday October 19, 2017 @05:44PM (#15511796)
Messaging people across countries, not worrying about what phone they had, or about having to pay extra money.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Friday October 20, 2017 @03:29AM (#15514093)
Yes, but we already had free messengers. As I pointed out in another post, Windows Live Messenger already worked on a bunch of phones (including J2ME).
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by praneshp on Friday October 20, 2017 @11:47PM (#15520552)
And yet Windows Live Messenger is dead and whatsapp is going strong. It was a piece of shit.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by raverbashing on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:15AM (#15508600)
Mobile first messaging system that worked even in feature phones
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:49AM (#15508911)
Windows Live Messenger, just as a random example, had apps for J2ME, Windows Mobile, BlackBerry and later iOS, besides the desktop.

Is "mobile first" an euphemism for "doesn't have a native desktop client"?

Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by peoplewindow on Thursday October 19, 2017 @08:39PM (#15512729)
No. In this case "mobile first" meant that their user identity was a phone number, not a username or email address.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Friday October 20, 2017 @03:23AM (#15514067)
Thanks. I think that's in fact an innovation. Were they the first?
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by peoplewindow on Friday October 20, 2017 @11:01PM (#15520452)
I believe so. The first I remember anyway.
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by seppin on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:03PM (#15509075)
Are you asking why Whatsapp is better than Windows Live Messenger?
Re:How the Frightful Five Put Startups in a Lose-Lose Situation by icebraining on Thursday October 19, 2017 @01:24PM (#15509748)
No, I'm asking why it's more innovative than Windows Live Messenger.

This debasement of the concept of innovation is exactly what I'm railing against.

I think Whatsapp is a good app, and their business is obviously successful. I just don't see the innovations. And I think it's important to preserve the word for those who merit it, even if they don't have the interest or skill to build a successful business.