News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Students learn more effectively from print textbooks than... by the_af on Thursday October 19, 2017 @10:44AM (#15508343)
I'm unsure... E-readers are wonderfully convenient to store multiple novels, but my experience is the same as in your previous post, even for novels. I tend to read non-sequentially -- going backwards and forwards in novels, re-reading previous chapters, going back a bit to re-read a paragraph I liked -- and e-readers are simply not good for that. Printed books are way better. I tend to remember what I read in paper books better than ebooks, exactly what you described for academic papers!
Re:Students learn more effectively from print textbooks than... by danmaz74 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @11:23AM (#15508674)
I guess that reading novels non-sequentially is enough of a special case...
Re:Students learn more effectively from print textbooks than... by the_af on Thursday October 19, 2017 @12:02PM (#15509051)
Is it? I don't mean "reading randomly, out of order" nor do I mean skipping to the end to read spoilers (though some people, puzzingly, do just that). I mean randomly reading parts I've already read. I assume a lot of people's reading habits are similar to mine.
Re:Students learn more effectively from print textbooks than... by extra88 on Thursday October 19, 2017 @02:52PM (#15510579)
I don't do that and have never heard of someone doing that. I have heard of people re-reading a chapter they just finished, because they enjoyed it so much or because they felt they missed something. I've heard of people opening a favorite novel to a random page, reading for a bit, then closing it.

The only non-sequential access I ever do in novels is for reference material, things like maps, character lists (e.g. Game of Thrones), or glossaries (e.g. Clockwork Orange). Footnotes on paper are sequential-ish, I read the Three Body Problem novels on a Kindle where you tap on a footnote number to get the text in a separate window and there's close or back button to return to the original page. I heard at least one David Foster Wallace novel had some insanely long footnotes that went on for multiple pages and maybe footnotes within footnotes, I don't know how that works on paper or an e-reader in terms of navigation.