Re:The Supreme Court Will Decide If the US Can Access Anyone...
by toomuchtodo on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @12:27AM
(#15488660)
EU companies (typically) don't have a nexus or operating presence in the US, therefore they can't be coerced to release requested data (unless the US Government is going to request three letter agencies to null route their traffic at internet exchanges [or take other adverse actions against their traffic]).
Your shell game you suggest will not withstand the scrutiny of an intelligent judge and an aggressive prosecutor.
Source: A lifetime ago, I was asked as a consultant to spec and site infrastructure out of the reach of the US government with the help of an international law attorney.
Re:The Supreme Court Will Decide If the US Can Access Anyone...
by manfredo on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @12:34AM
(#15488685)
What's to keep the US government from fining companies or suspending their ability to do business until they give up user data? For example, London suspending Uber's ability to operate in the city.
While I'd agree that small-ish foreign companies can probably fly under the radar, I don't think any company that receives payments from US customers is immune to coercion from the US. If the US government can impede a company's ability to access US customers then that's an ability to compel a company to give up data.
I'm not sure how resilient this is to coercion by the US government. Maybe the US government could forbid Microsoft from doing business with the data trustee unless the the trustee gives up user data.
1. https://news.microsoft.com/europe/2015/11/11/45283/