News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by xenadu02 on Monday October 16, 2017 @10:34PM (#15488229)
In physics (and in many other areas) it is unsatisfying to wave your hands and say "it is so because our measurements prove it". A theoretical model that explains why the measurements come out the way they do is far more valuable because it leads to other insights.

We can predict the behavior of a gyro but there is still a fundamental question of what a gyro is relative to since GR tells us there is no universal reference frame. Are gyroscopes entirely local or does the gravity of distant galaxies present a sort of universal reference frame? Or is it something else entirely?

Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by justinpombrio on Monday October 16, 2017 @10:51PM (#15488298)
> Are gyroscopes entirely local or does the gravity of distant galaxies present a sort of universal reference frame? Or is it something else entirely?

Something else entirely. You don't need other galaxies or a universal reference frame. Even if the gyroscope were the only thing in the universe, it would be easy to tell if it were spinning: a very tiny person standing on the inside rim would be held down if it were spinning, or free floating if it were not.

Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by monochromatic on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @12:37AM (#15488693)
This is exactly what Mach’s principle disputes.
Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by phkahler on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @09:35AM (#15490733)
Then Mach's principle is a straw man, we do not have access to an empty universe.
Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by fiddlerwoaroof on Monday October 16, 2017 @11:15PM (#15488396)
But that doesn't distinguish between the gyroscope spinning and the existence of a sufficiently massive object in the appropriate place, right?
Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by letlambda on Monday October 16, 2017 @11:42PM (#15488511)
Walk around to the opposite side of the gyro wheel. If the acceleration is due to the rotation of the gyroscope, it still points out radially. If it was due to a mass out beyond the rim, you're falling on your head.
Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by apsophus on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @12:32AM (#15488672)
What if the mass is distributed in a ring surrounding the gyro at a distance? How would you distinguish between spinning versus mass in that case?

General Relativity may seem counterintuitive, but experimentally it really does seem to be the way our universe works. Starting out from the position that absolute motion is meaningless has proven remarkably fruitful. It's also something a lot of very smart people have been thinking about for a hundred years. Whether or not you find Mach's arguments plausible, they're fundamental philosphical claims and can't simply be dismissed through a half-baked thought experiment.

Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @01:45AM (#15488934)
> What if the mass is distributed in a ring surrounding the gyro at a distance? How would you distinguish between spinning versus mass in that case?

In that case, it wouldn't be drawing you outward no matter where you were located. So, spinning would be "you feel a gravitational force", and a ring of mass would be "you don't feel a gravitational force".

Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by jfhufl on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @11:35AM (#15491791)
Seems to me the main difference is that all the particles in the gyro are trying to go in a straight line, but can't due to being a part of a rigid structure. You should be able to tell the difference by dropping a ball bearing. It will land "straight down" if it's gravity, but move "to the side" if it's rotating.
Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by Neeek on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @12:51AM (#15488744)
which is obvious because a gyro is not rigid and has parts the move relative to each other, but would the entire system feel a force if exerted on it and correct it's orientation? What would it be "pointed" at? If it did, wouldn't that imply an absolute point of reference?
Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by epistasis on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @01:48AM (#15488945)
Not an absolute point of reference, but an inertial point of reference:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_frame_of_reference

Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by Neeek on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @02:44AM (#15489118)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_frame_of_reference#Ab...

Is what the entire article is about! That our idea of an intertial frame of reference is incomplete.

Re:The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia by phkahler on Tuesday October 17, 2017 @09:41AM (#15490783)
>> We can predict the behavior of a gyro but there is still a fundamental question of what a gyro is relative to since GR tells us there is no universal reference frame.

If one can see that the gyro is still pointing in the same direction, then one has already defined a reference frame. I can see confusion if we had a gyro spinning inside a free-falling elevator (or even a closed box spinning in space). You can still tell the gyro is spinning because there are internal stresses that indicate the axis of rotation, if not the direction. The earth bulges at the equator because of its rotation, it would require much force to keep it spherical.