Re:Importance of “working out” math in school for a programmer
by brudgers on Monday October 16, 2017 @12:37PM
(#15484514)
If the exercise is demotivating there are two potentially useful things that can be gained. First, it is an opportunity to practice a discipline around doing the grunt work necessary for expert practice. The second is that doing that grunt work may be too high a price to pay for expertise in a particular field (i.e. that the field is not for you).
From my personal life, at one point I thought I wanted to be a chemist. I loved the theory to the point that I enjoyed reading the organic chemistry text book. But I also had to take analytic chemistry which was five credit hours and two days of lab a week and I only got a D by setting the curve on the written final...and the way I did that was by reading the analytic chemistry textbook cover to cover in the three preceding days, I had long since stopped going to lab.
In retrospect (retrospect at the time), I realized that I had always hated science lab. The reason I hated it was because science labs are designed around getting the correct answer that is already known...i.e. the teacher wrote down the composition of the unknown beforehand. [1]
Later having spent time in creative studio environments, I can rule out that my dislike was from the shared space. What I love about studio environments is people are being creative and feeding off of each other. Sure it's competitive, but the competition belongs to the players and wowing and being wowed by one's peers is different from the rote exercise that is an undergraduate science lab.
So I never became a chemist and that's because I never really had a personality for a career as a scientist. It's almost certainly a good thing for me that I did not. Which does not mean that is the case for everyone.
Anyway, the two things are not orthogonal. A person can strive to develop grunt work discipline in a field in which
they have no interest in pursuing further. The discipline has value because even my neighbor the painter gets up some mornings and paints paintings to sell because, you know, it's money.
Good luck.
[1]: Looking at it now, it seems absurd that the standard practice involves keeping knowledge secret.
From my personal life, at one point I thought I wanted to be a chemist. I loved the theory to the point that I enjoyed reading the organic chemistry text book. But I also had to take analytic chemistry which was five credit hours and two days of lab a week and I only got a D by setting the curve on the written final...and the way I did that was by reading the analytic chemistry textbook cover to cover in the three preceding days, I had long since stopped going to lab.
In retrospect (retrospect at the time), I realized that I had always hated science lab. The reason I hated it was because science labs are designed around getting the correct answer that is already known...i.e. the teacher wrote down the composition of the unknown beforehand. [1]
Later having spent time in creative studio environments, I can rule out that my dislike was from the shared space. What I love about studio environments is people are being creative and feeding off of each other. Sure it's competitive, but the competition belongs to the players and wowing and being wowed by one's peers is different from the rote exercise that is an undergraduate science lab.
So I never became a chemist and that's because I never really had a personality for a career as a scientist. It's almost certainly a good thing for me that I did not. Which does not mean that is the case for everyone.
Anyway, the two things are not orthogonal. A person can strive to develop grunt work discipline in a field in which they have no interest in pursuing further. The discipline has value because even my neighbor the painter gets up some mornings and paints paintings to sell because, you know, it's money.
Good luck.
[1]: Looking at it now, it seems absurd that the standard practice involves keeping knowledge secret.