https://spectrum.ieee.org/telecom/wireless/the-end-of-spectrum-scarcity
https://www.salon.com/2003/03/12/spectrum/
Basically, the argument is that interference (as understood in spectrum policy) is a myth. The channel capacity of a frequency band is a limit between two distinct physical points--it's not some global (or even local) limit. If you put two pairs of broadcasters and receivers in the same room using the same band, the laws of nature don't require that the available capacity to each pair be cut in half. It's the same as it was before for each pair; any reduction in throughput is merely a limitation of their particular technology. As sensitivity improves; as algorithms improve; as processing power increases; you can asymptotically approach your original (uncontended) throughput even as more transmitters join the fray.The above articles are fairly old, but their arguments have born out, and the fundamental science isn't contested. MIMO, beamforming, software defined radio, and other approaches are now widespread and have permitted orders of magnitude more _aggregate_ throughput for the same geographical area, even as the number of transmitters has dramatically increased. And things will only continue to improve for the foreseeable future.
It's not literally true that interference is a myth. And there are fundamental physical limitations that we'll eventually bump up against. But those fundamental limits are beyond the horizon. In the context of historic and contemporary spectrum policy, interference is indeed a myth.
The above technologies have come to fruition slower than free spectrum proponents argued. But their argument has always been that as long as government treats spectrum as scarce and grants legally protected monopoly rights, there's less market incentive to develop those technologies.
The fundamental argument isn't that we need to add more bands to mobile, but that we need to remove (or at least loosen) the regulations which artificially constrain contention. If market participants had to deal with more band contention, there'd be more incentive to improve their technology to restore the service quality. As long as you don't have malicious people intentionally trying to disrupt the system, the argument is that market incentives alone would spur technological improvements at least as fast as contended usage grew.
Of course, for the deployed technology at any particular point in time, more spectrum is better. But the argument here is about optimal long-term policy, not about the best way to ensure first responders can communicate 6 months from now.
The FCC deals with the world as it is, not with theory. When over the air television was designed, you couldn’t put the computational power into a TV to do true kind of interference rejection a modern WiFi system can do. Heck, even a more modern system like HDTV has miserable interference rejection. Transmit something else on the same frequency as a TV channel and see how much of a myth interference is.
You’re right of course that the FCC’s model of splitting uses by frequency band treats the issue as one dimensional, while in reality there are opportunities for spatial and temporal reuse. But you need computational horsepower to take advantage of that, and the necessary computational horsepower is really just now becoming available.
I certainly think it would be interesting to have the FCC allocate a band that could be used in a less regulated way such as you describe.
It's a very interesting area of SDR and game theory and I've actually put a bit of thought into how such an ecosystem might work after hearing a talk about the DARPA Spectrum Challenge.
So I don't disagree with your point at all, and think that the FCC should allocate some spectrum to this sort of deregulated scenario. Perhaps if it also required that all protocol and modulation approaches be open sourced that would help participants to coordinate usefully.
I think that we are far from the limits of physics across most of the network, but there are likely some congestion patterns in dense areas that create complex intermod scenarios that would make a system like this somewhat brittle until the ecosystem evolved to find a cooperative equilibrium of some sort.
In addition to MIMO, I'm interested in things like using TDM and awareness of harmonic and intermod characteristics to create various emergent latency "contracts" that correlated with different frequency ranges and time slices, so that participants that did not need low latency could create significantly less interference than they otherwise would, and participants could cooperate based on the data rate and latency requirements of other nearby nodes.
Technology may help, and the technological effects mentioned in the articles do happen but there is a fundamental limit
> Technology may help, and the technological effects mentioned in the articles do happen but there is a fundamental limit
Parent mentioned exactly that in their comment.
And that is the part I disagree
Especially when you have a large amount of people in the same place (stadium, busy street, etc) Or even your office wifi
There is a fundamental limit and we are at it in many scenarios and we've been for a very long time.
Bits of data delivered at or above minimum tolerable latency per hz of RF bandwidth per second?
Which spectrum do you think should be reallocated to mobile use?
> This "natural scarcity" is a property of the deployed technology, not of the universe.
What frequencies do you think should be used for mobile voice and data that are not already?