News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bach on a mobius strip by baddox on Sunday July 25, 2010 @07:42PM (#1546639)
Is there really anything to this other than the idea itself of playing a riff backward and forward at the same time? The idea is fascinating, but I don't think this piece sounds good at all, especially compared to J.S. Bach's more "conventional" pieces.
Re:Bach on a mobius strip by jberryman on Sunday July 25, 2010 @09:29PM (#1546806)
Yes it's about the idea, but the idea is hugely important to Bach. Baroque music was centered around this idea of an "economy of material": letting a single small kernel of an idea unfold into an entire piece of music. That's how Bach's brain worked; he could think of a simple theme and improvise a 5-voice fugue based on just a few notes.

This canon comes from his "Musical Offering" which are a set of pieces dedicated to Frederick the Great of Prussia (a flutist like me :-) ) all based on a single awkward theme given to him by the king, as a kind of challenge.

So I guess my point is when you look at this as one of a collection of many variations, renderings, and re-imaginings of a single short melody, with an eye to the importance that Bach placed on the aesthetic idea of an economy of material, that this becomes more than just a clever trick.

Although I agree Bach probably wrote it in less time than it took him to write it down. And I don't think he would have imagined people after his death would be playing it, let alone making CGI youtube videos and run-on sentences discussing it on internet message boards. :)

Re:Bach on a mobius strip by baddox on Monday July 26, 2010 @01:43AM (#1547250)
I can appreciate this as a piece of constrained writing, like a lipogram or univocalic, but apart from that context I think it lacks a pleasing musical quality which is present in much of Bach's work. That said, I would have loved to have experienced J. S. Bach's harpsichord improvisations.
Re:Bach on a mobius strip by noahlt on Sunday July 25, 2010 @10:02PM (#1546880)
Keep in mind that this was a pretty bad recording; it sounds like a (badly) synthesized acoustic guitar. Professional, live recordings of Bach's Musical Offering include the Crab Canon and sound much better.