News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by aloisdg on Friday October 13, 2017 @07:55AM (#15464814)
Capitalism is an economic system and an ideology based on private ownership of the means of production and their operation for profit. You want creativity? Leave capitalism.
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by matt4077 on Friday October 13, 2017 @08:14AM (#15464907)
> Capitalism is an economic system and an ideology

That's the problem right there: Capitalism has proven to be excellent at organising an economy. It's excellent! It works with human nature. The largest problems automatically provide the largest reward for solving! It locates decisions at the lowest possible level!

The problem is when people use it as an ideology, i. e. as an end to itself. Intellectual property, for example, with its zero marginal costs, isn't as good a fit for capitalism as wheat: When you're charging $10 for a movie, many people will not watch it because it's only worth $5 to them. That's an inefficiency as glaring as communism ever produced, because it is value lost as a tribute to keeping the structure intact, even though no work would be required for it at all.

There are many more inefficiencies of capitalism that we conveniently ignore. The complete finance sector is nothing but the bureaucracy needed to organise capitalism. Competition is a great method to get better results, but it also involves a lot of duplicated efforts. Advertisement is–and this is the usual argument of people defending it-neccessary for the functioning of capitalism because it spreads information the market needs. The inequality needed to serve as motivation breeds unhappiness and crime.

These aren't arguments to abandon capitalism, because it quite obviously is the best system we've found so far. But that shouldn't preclude us from trying alternatives, especially in niches that are so different that the outcomes may be different from the traditional production of physical goods.

Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by ameister14 on Friday October 13, 2017 @09:29AM (#15465406)
I don't think you described capitalism as an ideology. You seem to simply be talking about inefficiencies in capitalist execution.

Capitalism as ideology is a bit different. For example, if someone is rich, they are higher status, but not only that - they are assumed to have innate characteristics that make them better, such as discipline and intelligence. We've created, and this predates capitalism and allowed for its spread, a social system that equates wealth with social power.

That's a part of capitalism as an ideology. Another part is that people automatically view things in terms of cost. They weigh choices in monetary terms, as opposed to social, moral or physical.

I disagree with your example of capitalist inefficiency, as well - you've chosen a price equilibrium inefficiency but you're using that example to illustrate that a product is ill-suited for capitalism. It isn't; if the movie was priced correctly, the inefficiency would disappear. Plus, as you pointed out, there are negligible costs for distribution (it's not really zero, but who cares) so profits on a product like that would be significant. That seems to me to be a better product for capitalist exploitation than wheat.

Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by matt4077 on Friday October 13, 2017 @01:18PM (#15467531)
> I don't think you described capitalism as an ideology

I wasn't trying to. I was saying that it works well as a means of organisation, before pointing out its weaknesses. Ideology is when you ignore those weaknesses, and try to shoehorn everything within the framework of capitalism.

> If the movie was priced correctly, the inefficiency would disappear

The problem is that it's hard to price it efficiently, because the value is different for different people. You can try price-separation, i. e. by geography, or the cascade of movie theatre to download to broadcast TV. But there's still a loss of welfare. As another example: I will never pay for a subscription to the WSJ, or to Adobe Creative Cloud, or to NGINX Plus. But my life would be marginally better if I had access to these products. And the only reason I don't is because there's no way to allow people like me access, without also allowing those free access that are currently paying.

Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by ameister14 on Friday October 13, 2017 @04:38PM (#15469074)
Ideology isn't when you ignore something's weaknesses and shoehorn everything within its framework. Blind adherence to an ideology can cause that, but it's not what the word means.
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by wu-ikkyu on Friday October 13, 2017 @09:17AM (#15465306)
>The largest problems automatically provide the largest reward for solving!

Is global warming a large problem? Because it would seem the destruction of the environment is highly profitable under the current system.

Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by noxToken on Friday October 13, 2017 @09:46AM (#15465562)
No. That's a side-effect of a highly profitable market. Subtle but important difference.
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by wu-ikkyu on Friday October 13, 2017 @10:44AM (#15466123)
The OP said the largest problems get the highest reward. Not markets.

What is a more important problem, having a environment to live in, or being able to use fossil fuels?

Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by PoachedSausage on Friday October 13, 2017 @08:52AM (#15465118)
Capitalism works well with, and propagates some aspects of human nature (whatever that is).

Due to our evolutionary past, humans are more focused on the physically nearby, the present and very near future, so capitalism fails when we have longterm wide-scale problems to solve, like climate change.

Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by pmontra on Friday October 13, 2017 @08:53AM (#15465122)
> The largest problems automatically provide the largest reward for solving!

In principle yes, but there are ways to game the system. Marketing is very good at creating false problems and aim consumers at them. Many of the things we work at are pretty much useless.

[dead]
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by sctb on Friday October 13, 2017 @01:15PM (#15467506)
We've banned this account for repeatedly violating the guidelines.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by philippnagel on Friday October 13, 2017 @08:02AM (#15464848)
Communism is not the only alternative to Capitalism. Also it is worth to discuss whether a self-described communist system was truly communist.
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by pault on Friday October 13, 2017 @08:11AM (#15464891)
Also, pure communism, enlightened despotism and all other political ideologies that require top-down control, seem to all have the same failure mode. The violence is a side effect of the authoritarianism, not the economic model (I think). More democratic societies have fewer and less lethal political purges. I don't know what a fully democratic pure communist system would look like but I'd be very interested in seeing how it played out.
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by 24gttghh on Friday October 13, 2017 @09:28AM (#15465399)
Maybe it can't exist as long as there are those who seek the aggrandizement which leads to a consolidation of power. If you have a state that owns everything, there will be people that will abuse such authority. Could there be a communist economic model alongside a multi-party state model?
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by KekDemaga on Friday October 13, 2017 @08:11AM (#15464892)
Communism Light, all that great communism flavor with less murder (so far)
Re:Tech companies are misusing creativity in their quest to ... by sctb on Friday October 13, 2017 @01:11PM (#15467478)
Please stop trolling.