News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Touch of Madness by taneq on Thursday October 12, 2017 @04:47AM (#15456565)
> When the director of the World Health Organization's mental-health unit, Shekhar Saxena, was asked last year where he'd prefer to be if he were diagnosed with schizophrenia, he said for big cities he'd prefer a city in Ethiopia or Sri Lanka, like Colombo or Addis Ababa, rather than New York or London, because in the former he could expect to be seen as a productive if eccentric citizen rather than a reject and an outcast.

I can't help feeling that this is based on some pretty skewed statistics. Someone in Colombo or Addis Ababa who's 'a bit odd might' well be seen as as 'productive if eccentric'. I don't expect a first world country would be any different. But the question is how do people further down the spectrum end up faring, and I can't imagine a raving lunatic would do better, on average, in a big city in a poor country than they would in a similarly big city in a rich country.

Re:The Touch of Madness by SomeStupidPoint on Thursday October 12, 2017 @05:09AM (#15456652)
> I can't imagine a raving lunatic would do better, on average, in a big city in a poor country than they would in a similarly big city in a rich country

Is this anything but an argument from failure of imagination?

As a neutral observer, it seems more likely that the director of the WHO's mental health unit is informed about the experiences of the mentally ill across the globe than your hunches are. My hunch about statistics is that your feeling about statistics is rooted in unsupported beliefs about your society as opposed to facts.

I think the implication is that some places (Ethiopia or Sri Lanka) are more open in what constitutes "a bit odd" versus "deranged" than others (US or UK), and that this greatly impacts outcome once you account for general conditions of living (ie, only talking about big cities).

> I can't imagine a raving lunatic would do better

Notice how you jumped to an extreme to make your point -- raving lunatics are unlikely to do well anywhere so there is unlikely to be much variation in the outcome for them, you are correct. But what does the distribution look like? The median? The mode? etc. The vast majority of schizophrenics aren't raving lunatics -- though they are very susceptible to how they're interacted with by society.

I'm inclined to believe that when discussing the distribution of outcomes, the expected outcome on average is better where the WHO director believes it is.

Re:The Touch of Madness by coldtea on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:29AM (#15458188)
>But the question is how do people further down the spectrum end up faring, and I can't imagine a raving lunatic would do better, on average, in a big city in a poor country than they would in a similarly big city in a rich country.

You'd be surprised. E.g. rural communities used to treat their "raving lunatics" much better than rich countries with their work schedules, lack of knowing each other, impersonal support networks (e.g. charities and soup kitchens), etc. Consider all the "raving lunatics" that are left to wonder and cater for themselves as homeless, and then are routinely discriminated, beaten up, thrown out of parks, etc. Heck, ordinary citizens feel out of place, get (situationally) depressed, and anxious in such big cities, much less a "lunatic" where it's either homelessness, or some atrocious asylum.

This also means that the people not that far right in the spectrum, might also be better off in those societies -- here the totally OK people already are pressured by the pace, loneliness, etc. We do have more drugs to throw at them, I'll admit to that.

Re:The Touch of Madness by psyc on Thursday October 12, 2017 @10:41AM (#15458290)
I only have experience with the US. My experience has been that if people detect even a hint of eccentric or crackpot about you, they hospitalize you at worst, shun you on average, and condescend to you like an invalid at best. With the right context, you might be able to spin it into an acceptable narrative, for example if you are an artist. From what I have read, other countries offer more such narratives.
Re:The Touch of Madness by mercer on Thursday October 12, 2017 @09:37AM (#15457807)
Anecdotally my experience living in a very poor country is that even the extremely schizophrenic can have a much better life than the one they'd have in my current rich, Western country (Netherlands).

However, this outcome depended on whether these individuals had a social network that could support them. The severely mentally ill (or for that matter, also the physically disabled or orphaned) without such a network fared significantly worse than they would over here in Holland.

In fact, their situation was sometimes so bad that I'd go for the 'clinical' and flawed but consistent just to avoid that. I still feel there's a middle ground to explore, though, or at least a lot of inspiration to draw from.