Re:Eloquent JavaScript, 3rd edition
by kaishiro on Thursday October 12, 2017 @02:17AM
(#15456015)
Eloquent JavaScript is easily the text I most reference when asked for recommendations on where to go to learn/bone up on JS. It's a real achievement, in one guy's opinion.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think Eloquent JS is a fan fruckin tastic book, overall. BUT, I have one quibble (about the first edition; I haven't looked at the second).
Its preface and first few chapters sort of present itself as a book intended to teach the absolute basics of programming to someone who has never done any programming at all before. A first book. And I think you'll find that if you give it as a sole resource to someone in that position, it just moves too quickly through the fundamentals. It's definitely a second book or a third book, or a book for reading after someone made it through a few of those ultra-beginner courses on Codecademy or Khan Academy or wherever.
I actually completely agree. I usually work with people who have already had some exposure to basic programming concepts and I think it's wonderful for them. But for someone looking to get started there are presumably better resources.
Agreed. Once you hit that recursion/functions in functions chapter...lawd. And I'm coming from python (almost intermediate level)
I can confirm this as well. I actually have Eloquent Javascript queued up because the first time I read it, I found it too challenging. And even then I wasn't a complete beginner.
That said: I love this book!
Re:Eloquent JavaScript, 3rd edition
by irrational on Thursday October 12, 2017 @02:23AM
(#15456033)
Have you read You Don't Know JavaScript? I'm just wondering how you feel the two compare.
I have, and they're also a great resource. I tool up a lot of junior devs, and I usually start them off on Eloquent if only because the format really lends itself to structured lessons. I like YDKJS post-Eloquent, for when they really want to dig into something specific (closures, async, etc). I think the two collective works marry pretty nicely.