Re:The privilege of risk
by evolve2017 on Wednesday October 11, 2017 @06:14PM
(#15454001)
Your parents' story is very impressive, but I think it highlights some aspects of privilege I have also encountered:
- The people who are able to emigrate from a poor/devastated country are generally the educated and former middle class
- Airfare is expensive, and in real terms was more expensive in the past; two tickets across the Atlantic probably represent more than most humans will ever make in their lives
- Some people are being rounded up/denied the right to enter the country on their visas. Even having the chance to roll the dice on life in the US is a huge advantage
I could go on.
I think it's uncomfortable to think of ourselves as anything but eminently worthy/self-reliant but this doesn't hold up to close scrutiny. I say this as the child of immigrants who now are worth millions but used to work security, after arriving with $100 in their pockets.
Re:The privilege of risk
by dvt on Wednesday October 11, 2017 @06:19PM
(#15454031)
You're right in the sense that we're all privileged in comparison to, say, rural Kenyans. But that's not what the original article was arguing. I feel that you're attacking a straw man here.
- The people who are able to emigrate from a poor/devastated country are generally the educated and former middle class
- Airfare is expensive, and in real terms was more expensive in the past; two tickets across the Atlantic probably represent more than most humans will ever make in their lives
- Some people are being rounded up/denied the right to enter the country on their visas. Even having the chance to roll the dice on life in the US is a huge advantage
I could go on.
I think it's uncomfortable to think of ourselves as anything but eminently worthy/self-reliant but this doesn't hold up to close scrutiny. I say this as the child of immigrants who now are worth millions but used to work security, after arriving with $100 in their pockets.