Investors in Facebook should have the concept of "due diligence" applied to them. Trading in pre-IPO stock is not and should not be safeguarded like regular equities or FDIC insured bank deposits.
Ultimately this is Zuckerberg's fault, and any settlements from this case should be paid from his assets.
I think it all rests on whether or not the statute of limitations started ticking before July 2004. According to New York Civil Practice Law & Rules - ยง 213, which I believe is pertinent to the case, it mentions "two years from the time the plaintiff...could with reasonable diligence have discovered it".
If Ceglia exercised his right to those shares so early in the stage, those people could have easily been poached by Google or started another company.
Just because Peter Thiel and other investors valued it highly doesn't make it so. Would you agree with his investment in largely failed Friendster? No one should be beholden to imaginary valuations by pre-IPO investors who have a higher tolerance for risk.
Surely the value of the company's shares is however much investors are willing to pay for them?
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1537158
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1510528
[1]Which, as a side note, drives home just how much better HN is than most other places on the internet, we got lengthy analyses, almost everywhere else was overrun with re-phrasings of "Oh boy Zuckerberg's fucked now!".