News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by blub on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:01AM (#15441391)
Type systems are not enough. I'm not sure they're even a good starting point for safety critical software, but they might be good for e.g browsers.

You're thinking at code level, people like Leveson, Knight and others are thinking at system level. The end goal is to have a safe system, not e.g avoid null pointer exceptions through optional types.

Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by gipp on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:21AM (#15441508)
I'm not sure you're familiar enough with what a sufficiently powerful type system can accomplish. A full dependent type system is sufficient to statically prove that code meets a given specification. We're not just talking about ints and strings and optionals when we talk about type systems for correct software. See Curry-Howard correspondence.
Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by blub on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:38AM (#15441637)
Do I need to know more than what you said - that they can prove that code meets a spec?

This can work awesome for small programs and clear algorithms, but as is hinted in the article, one has to first create a correct specification.

I gave an example in another post, here's another: unforeseen interactions between two components built to spec.

Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by planteen on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:47AM (#15441707)
I completely agree - most often the spec is wrong. For example, it doesn't matter if you have a completely correct implementation of Euler angles for a control system. If gimbal lock wasn't considered in the spec, you are going to have issues.
Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by kazinator on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @10:04AM (#15441837)
> I'm not sure you're familiar enough with what a sufficiently powerful type system can accomplish.

A sufficiently powerful type system can compute any partial recursive function at type check time. That's pretty much the upper bound.

Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by kazagistar on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @10:55AM (#15442292)
The upper bound is arbitrary code, and validating arbitrary proofs.
Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by sheepmullet on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:55AM (#15441777)
> I'm not sure you're familiar enough with what a sufficiently powerful type system can accomplish.

At what cost?

I'd estimate it to be at least 10x development cost.

Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by zoul on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:15AM (#15441472)
Optional types are a good example of how types make a system safer. Sure, they are a pretty low-level guarantee, but that still counts—�and if you have an expressive type system, you can make much higher-level guarantees with types.
Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by blub on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:24AM (#15441523)
I think they're great! I am pushing to use them in our C++ code base and they empirically do improve safety by transforming UB into a nice exception.

But they won't prevent a programmer from using MD5 for RSA signature verification.

Re:Is Uncle Bob serious? by dkersten on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:43AM (#15441668)
But if all of these things are correctly typed, then it would be visually more likely for someone to notice that the algorithm doesn't return the type it says.

Also, C++ static types are rather weak. Its optional types are useful, but its not like in SML where the compiler ensures that you handled all possible cases.

A good type system can't catch all kinds of errors though.