News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @02:15AM (#15439757)
> If you had enough dark matter sitting in some spot that could turn into a star, suddenly the claim is any ordinary matter around it would stay near absolute zero no matter how much nuclear fusion was going on at the same spot?

You can't. Because becoming a star (initiating nuclear fusion) requires nongravitational interaction between nucleons, which are normal, not dark, matter.

Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by throwaway613834 on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @02:21AM (#15439778)
I thought the claim was that dark matter doesn't interact with normal matter through other forces, not that it doesn't interact with itself?

But if so... then dark matter might be just bosons? The properties I'm reading seem to be pretty consistent with bosons.

Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @02:27AM (#15439801)
IIUC, If it interacts with itself through other forces, they can't be through the forces that act on normal matter (which they would interact with if that was the case), including the forces involved in nuclear fusion. They'd have to be dark matter exclusive forces.
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by throwaway613834 on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @02:29AM (#15439810)
Interesting, thanks. So what's preventing "dark matter" from simply being, say, lots of photons traveling through intergalactic space then? That seems like the next obvious candidate after ordinary matter.
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by gus_massa on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @06:41AM (#15440745)
If dark matter where a lot of photons, then we could detect it. For example the experiments to detect the cosmic microwave background radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_microwave_background can detect a very small amount of light that is the leftover of the radiation produced soon after the big bang. We have very good estimations of how many photons are out there.
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by throwaway613834 on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @09:58AM (#15441801)
I don't understand, how would you detect photons that are going in a direction orthogonal to you in intergalactic space? They have to be coming toward you for you to detect them, right?
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by eipipuz on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @02:26PM (#15444129)
An implicit assumption is that the universe is isotropic and homogenous at that scale. Meaning, it looks the same from any point and any direction.

So you might not detect photons in one particular direction, but we should assume that they should be going in all directions. Otherwise that theory is just moving the goal from "where's this energy" to "why is it pointing towards that".

CMB is consistent with, every direction is the same, so you would have to say "photons are going everywhere in this range, but towards that in this segment of the spectrum".

Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by throwaway613834 on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @02:47PM (#15444307)
But isn't it a hell of a lot less of a stretch to imagine there are more photons in other parts of the universe than here, than to imagine there is some sort of mysterious dark matter permeating all of the universe? If we're going to be unable to interact with whatever dark matter is to test may hypothesis, we might as well propose the hypothesis that requires the least radical changes to our fundamental theories of physics, no?
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by eipipuz on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @11:49PM (#15447148)
Assume have an equation like `Energy = 0`, where `Energy = Mass + Photons`. It works great for almost everything, we can get the curvature of space by `f(Energy)` where `f(Photons) = 0`.

However there's this one experiment that says the answer is `Energy = 42`. `f(x)` is still useful, everything else works.

We can just amend the equation to be: `Energy = Mass + Photons + DarkMatter` where `DarkMatter = -42` and `f(DarkMatter) = 0`.

Or we can keep the E=M+P but change the way f works to be: `f(Photons, X) = Y` where for almost any value `f(Photons, X') = 0` and in this one case `f(Photons, X") = 42`.

To me it's clear that the first approach is less complicated. The first approach raises one question, "why -42?" The second approach raises "why does X?" exist and "why 42?"

======

By the way, you are mistaken, we do interact with Dark Matter, that's how we detected it (Bullet Cluster). Gravity does interact with it.

Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by gnaritas on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @02:52AM (#15439889)
Photons lack mass right?
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by throwaway613834 on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @04:12AM (#15440173)
Well I read [1] [2] that they do have gravity... which is probably a more direct answer to what you're asking. I'm not sure what counts as "mass" for a photon per se, except that I assume there's an effective mass via the energy.

[1] https://www.quora.com/How-does-a-photon-exert-gravitational-...

[2] https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/22878

Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by posterboy on Tuesday October 10, 2017 @04:04AM (#15440138)
not exactly. As photons are constantly moving at the speed of light (citing the theory of relativity I don't really understand) they have no resting mass. But they have an impuls and create a force of impact (used in sun sails) from which a theoretical notion of ... mass (kinetic, perhaps?) can be derived. I'd like to know how it's derived originally, too though.

edit: if E=mc² with E(photon)=f•h and f=c/λ, then m=h/(λc) in vacuum. ... I hope that's correct. What's interesting, [m]=J/[a]/m

Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by gnaritas on Wednesday October 11, 2017 @04:31PM (#15453177)
Normally when discussing mass, people are referring to resting mass, not relativistic mass.
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by posterboy on Thursday October 12, 2017 @03:22AM (#15456252)
normally, people don't discuss mass. rather they are simply heavy. most don't even really care why. and those who do, conflate the idea with weight often enough.
Re:First detection of the missing half of normal matter in o... by gnaritas on Thursday October 12, 2017 @01:33PM (#15459649)
haha, very true.