This creates a situation where the same $1 has less value to a poor person because it has interest paid attached, and $1 to a rich person will have interest/investment gained attached. It is that difference, as well as starting funds/wealth for investment, that creates the exponential growth for wealth and the enormous advantage wealth gives to market actors when inequality is high. Wealth grows at like O(n log n) or better, while poor wealth shrinks sometimes at less than O(1)
Combine that with rich people on average spending less of their overall wealth into the consumer economy (not just investments or hoarding it during down markets -- a problem that exacerbates crashes) and you have a system that will get much worse. Policy is failing currently at getting money to move to all parts of the economy and the velocity of money has fallen off a cliff and is in a freefall due to the hoarding/inequality that has grown since 2000 intensely [1].
Investment is the most important thing to growing wealth but also we can't just have an economy of only investment, someone needs to actually buy things in the economy.
Typically the lower/middle end spending keep the consumer economy afloat with larger spending on consumer products that make those investments worth it because there is demand. You have to have people buying for demand, to then invest in supply, demand always comes first or else wealth doesn't invest.
Further, wealth simply cannot buy enough to keep the whole economy afloat and wealthy people invest to retain more wealth not necessarily return it to the economy, whereas poor/middle range players spend to survive. When there is a market crash, wealth stops investing, poor/middle keeps on buying which is key. When there is inequality and only investment, downturns get harsher and harsher eradicating demand and thus eradicating investment opportunities.
To most people, the debt is just a magical number on a paper and means nothing to them so long as their daily activities remain unhindered. And indeed, if things go wrong what then? Same thing as rent vs. buying, you lose your place you file bankruptcy whatever. Makes no difference to the buyer.
The only conceivable alternative that you might like is not having to pay for your basic needs, but, that's not going to happen ever in a capitalist society. So good luck with that fantasy.
If there were no morts, you would have to amass wealth for a long time to be able to purchase a home, which means ur capital becomes tied and you cant invest. Mortgages increase the amount of circulating money enormously.
Everything is exponential in finance, both debts and house values. Also income and investment returns. The exponential nature of debt is not an argument against anything. Rental also has an exponential opportunity cost.
In the UK is that housing has become unaffordable for most of the population - precisely because mortgages made it possible to buy property as an investment.
At the same time the market has been deliberately starved of affordable housing as a matter of national policy.
So your point makes no sense. What are you going to do with capital while you're saving it for a property purchase? Keep it under a mattress?
In reality, without mortgages, there would be far more investment cash available, because the money would be out there doing something useful, not trapped and congealed inside a fixed asset.
> In the UK is that housing has become unaffordable for most of the population - precisely because mortgages made it possible to buy property as an investment.
Without going too deep, there is a problem with saying unaffordable. Are we talking about indigents? Or that the middle class 25-35 doesn't have the access to houses the previous generation had? They are very different propositions.
I would take for granted that mortgages raise the price of housing, simply because it helps foster demand more than supply. But it also means more houses are sold, which also means more houses are built. The goal is not to have cheap housing, is for the biggest amount of people getting housing, and banning mortgages will reduce both prices and people getting housing.
> At the same time the market has been deliberately starved of affordable housing as a matter of national policy.
I can't comment or debate about this for UK because I don't know what this is about. Any government that puts a policy to control what is built is likely going to have bad effects. It is true that luxury housing is providing higher returns than affordable in the U.S. In argentina its a bit different, due to historically no credit: basically the only buyers of new property in Argentina are investors, because those are the only ones that had the capital to purchase in advance. Hence for a decade, the market was flooded with cheap-construction rental homes. I expect the introduction of mortgages to create a market for long-term quality housing.
> So your point makes no sense. What are you going to do with capital while you're saving it for a property purchase? Keep it under a mattress?
Probably low-yield money funds if you are sophisticated. Home-owners are ill-advised to mortgages their home to invest in the stock market: using your capital to buy a home to invest in stocks is basically the same.
> In reality, without mortgages, there would be far more investment cash available, because the money would be out there doing something useful, not trapped and congealed inside a fixed asset.
If a man buys a house at 100k, his capital is now owned by the former seller, so the amount of capital in circulation is the same. The point is what happens when someone wants to buy a house: they have decades of saving money in low yields. This can be seen in Argentina again, as there is a mortgage boom, 30 year olds are making cash-down payment, even though market participation is almost non-existent. People were saving the cash in their mattresses.
And I should be clear that I'm really lamenting about something bigger, which is the tendency for "always defect" strategies to get normalized as "smart" in our collective economy's various prisoners' dilemmas. We suffer collectively because of it.
More concretely: right now because of how cheap, bad quality mortgages artificially inflated housing prices around 2008, and again today, and because of the stagnancy of wages, most people I know cannot afford to buy or rent without compromising their well-being significantly.
If "cheap" mortgages weren't so rampant, how would property values even have been able to inflate like they did? They wouldn't... it'd be a totally different market. I think home values would be much closer to their physical value, reflecting the state that they're in rather than some abstract, speculative potential value. There would be less incentive for speculators to hold on to them for the sake of "investing" and more reason for people to hold on to them for the sake of living in them.
Just where does that money circulate back to? Right now it circulates back to the most wealthy, those who this article is talking about, those who are usurping their feudal lordships right now.
Where I live, there is a housing trust that bars people from buying its houses to rent them, and protects houses from bubbles. When people want to sell the houses, they have to sell them through the trust, where the amount they could lose or gain from market fluctuations alone is capped at 25%. If they made improvements on the house, they are able to sell it at a higher value. The houses are significantly less than market value. And are much higher quality than rental properties.
There are several explanations to housing values being high today besides (and probably along) cheap credit. 1) 2008 crisis was devastating to construction and development rates in the U.S. and it hasn't caught up to demographic growth. That alone could cause a mid-long term increase in housing prices that can only subside if development outstrips demo-growth 2) There is a global effect of people moving to cities for jobs. Even if construction kept up, if people moved to the cities where its harder and more expensive to build, you would see wages lagging behind property prices, since the competition for both gets more fiercely concentrated. 3) There is a global effect of chinese money. Cities like vancouver and London are very aware that the influx of asian funds have fueled their local RE markets.
Also, the era of cheap credit is ending, and the fed is slowing increasing the rates. They might be risking a crisis if they just jumped the credit a few points up, so this process can also take quite a while.
> Where I live, there is a housing trust that bars people from buying its houses to rent them, and protects houses from bubbles. When people want to sell the houses, they have to sell them through the trust, where the amount they could lose or gain from market fluctuations alone is capped at 25%. If they made improvements on the house, they able to sell it at a higher value. The houses are significantly less than market value. And are much higher quality than rental properties.
Any restriction of use of a commodity will reduce its value. Naturally, if you only allowed a housing unit to be rented out, it will also be of less value that one that doesn't have that restriction. In terms of housing, that is an equivalent to a price control, so those measures will tend to lower investment and availability, to, finally, in the end, cause higher prices than they would otherwise. Rent control is one classic case of this effect.
Moreover, its not a scalable solution, and I'm fairly confident that it will show all the problems of trying to avoid market behavior: it might be hard to get in to the fund, it might end up causing a run in the case of a big down-turn where many people need to sell but the fund has overpromised, etc etc.
What you're describing sounds exactly like the housing market under the rule of cheap mortgages and speculative investment. People having a hard time getting in, people having a hard time getting out without going bankrupt, these are all exactly what happened in the "free" housing market during the last decade.
Anyway I don't understand how this program "avoids" market behavior. In your mind, is the free market somehow incomplete without a rentier class?
I don't see the same effects you mention. If we talk pre-2008, getting in was too easy. Post-2008, to 2012 the market had a typical rebound curve, those were all good times to jump in. Now its expensive again, which means demand has to subsidize and start balancing out with the supply.
In 2009 i used to say argentina RE prices were too high for the population, and that some crash should happen. 2017 and it hasn't happened: its possible house prices as they are now are here to stay for a long time.
> Anyway I don't understand how this program "avoids" market behavior.
It tries to set its own prices by means of insurance. By making a fund that caps wins and losses, it doesn't prevent them, it just distributes them differently. There is pervasiveness to the concept of "you can't beat the market": it means that if you are, you are absorbing some risk or cost you don't see.
i.e.: What if a crisis happened that lowered house prices 40% across the board: 100% of the community wants to sell in the fund, which has capped losses, and then buy property again, to make a neat 15%. Moroever if the market goes up, as soon as the market shows 25% improvement, there is a great incentive to sell, because your gains are capped. So when you are close to that limit, your biggest interest is to sell, specially if property taxes adjust to a standard different from the one the fund uses.
Not to mention that you have to pay the people managing this fund one way or another: their labor does not come free.
These are all risks and consequences that exist on that management style alone.
> In your mind, is the free market somehow incomplete without a rentier class?
Not at all. And in this fund case, the fund managers are the rentiers.
If you bought a house through the trust at $100k, but now it's market value is $300k, you would only be able to sell it for an additional 25% of the appreciation ($50k).
Im not saying its a bad idea, or uninteresting, but its definitely not going to be superior to the general market as it is (afaik).
We have a system that is set up based on exponential functions; and we know that most people will intuit linear.
It is very frustrating watching friends people take up a position on the wrong side of an exponential function because they live in the here and now. Doubly so trying that they don't realise how big a financial gap they are creating to where they could be.
I flat out don't believe that most (ordinary, no maths training) people taking on debt understand whether they are making a good or bad decision. If they make a good call, it is luck.
You are comparing amounts of money at different points in time without discounting them to their NPV. That is nonsensical. Ironically, if you go to get a mortgage at a bank, they sometimes use the same arguments to steer you to their preferred mortgage (look how much more you would pay in total at the end of the ride for option A vs option B, without take the time value of money into account).
With homes, it turns our places of respite into worrisome baggage.
What does this even mean?
People rely on math that they vaguely understand to govern their financial and economic relationships.
For example, when you buy an over valued house with a mortgage, say during a housing bubble, it doesn't make sense for you to try and sell it later on for less than you originally "paid" (with your fancy loan). So you are going to hold onto it, waiting for the market to go "up", so that you can sell it to yet another person who takes out yet another loan to "pay" for this overpriced house. In the mean time, either you or some renter is busting their ass to pay the interest on that unnecessary loan. It's completely ordinary for people who who decided not too take a mortgage to get stuck paying the interest for someone who locked a house into debt.
This is completely straight forward but when I try to convey how absurd it is, a lot of common sense people look at me like I'm crazy. It's considered a financially "sound investment" to buy a house and try to sell it higher. Well what if I don't want to live in a world where everyone is just playing monopoly all the time? I feel like there are much more interesting and pressing things to do with our precious human time and energy than cater to these ridiculous cycles of debt.
And lot of people who take debt because it's so "smart" couldn't come up with an original exponential function if their life depended in it.