News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by jasode on Saturday October 07, 2017 @05:44PM (#15425867)
>Does anyone try to retain developer talent these days?

There's a line of thought which assumes that an employee that's given notice has already mentally "checked out". Therefore, it's unwise to present counteroffers. Even if the manager persuades the employee to accept the counteroffer, it's inadvertently detrimental to the team because you have retained a disengaged mind that was eager to leave. To avoid all that, you wish them well with a smile and just let them leave.

Many companies follow that principle. It's important for a developer to know ahead of time if the company doesn't do counteroffers because if you're just fishing around for job offers with no intention of changing jobs, the company may call your bluff and let you leave.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by fsloth on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:11AM (#15427291)
"There's a line of thought which assumes that an employee that's given notice has already mentally "checked out". Therefore, it's unwise to present counteroffers"

That's just bullshit rationalization why they don't want to raise pay. Profits come first for most modern companies, and the rationale for action trickles down from that basic driving force.

Best engineers are coin operated and problem focused. If they get an offer, say, 20% better than their current package with the roughly same job otherwise, they would be blind fools not to leave. Talking in the general Big Co. environment, that is. In smaller companies with stronger ties other dynamics might kick in.

And, there is the situation of the gimme-more-money-or-I'm-gone bluff, of course.

I don't think there is any rational reason not to give a counteroffer to a solid contributor - if the offer is real and he's worth it. Political reasons might of course kick in, like a corporate policy, that have nothing to do with the individual contributors motivation or output.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by rando444 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @11:57AM (#15428666)
If the employee just wanted more money and feels they are worth it, then all they have to do is ask.

If the employee already starts looking for another job without even trying to get more money in his current position, there is no reason to try and convince him to stay.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by JamesBarney on Sunday October 08, 2017 @12:07PM (#15428714)
Many places if you ask for more money you'll get "sorry you're at the top of your range". "we can only give raises during performance review". Then when you turn in your 2 weeks suddenly it's "if it's money you're looking it's no problem to give you a very large out of band raise. Why didn't you say something?"
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by fsloth on Sunday October 08, 2017 @01:58PM (#15429184)
"If the employee just wanted more money and feels they are worth it, then all they have to do is ask."

No. The calculus is different. If it's a raise, it merely increases the cost of an employee. A counteroffer on the other hand counters several costs and risks. Hiring, training, loss of knowledge etc.

"If the employee already starts looking for another job without even trying to get more money in his current position"

Why do you presume that is the general case? I.e. does not ask for money or that they sought for another job.

Best talent tries to get compensation their worth. They probably ask for raises - but they are probably also sought by recruitment consultants. If a raise is not coming, and a consultant asks for what they would be willing to work for - well, it's simply not a case of trying to leave.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by CyanLite3 on Sunday October 08, 2017 @04:45PM (#15429914)
True dat. What's worse is that I've seen some companies have a strict HR policy of not allowing out-of-band raises unless a physical letter of resignation was received. So some folks would try to negotiate with their front-line managers only to get rebuffed unless they actually resigned. Then they would pour out the counteroffers. None would ever take it in that scenario.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by scalesolved on Monday October 09, 2017 @06:47AM (#15432775)
In almost every job I've had I will approach for a raise with a list of my achievements, cost savings and recommendations. I will also indicate where I see my future impact and value specific to the business.

Most of the time I will get a standard small raise, if I take the same list out to the market and get an offer suddenly I qualify for higher raises. Overall businesses are not pro-active at all about retaining talent until push comes to shove.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by justanotherbody on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:16PM (#15429257)
A variety of workplaces have bureaucracy in place to require additional justification beyond manager and even manager + skip level approval.

Whatever your thoughts on the suitability of a workplace like this, know that the most time/effort efficient way to get a raise can legitimately be to show up with an offer which demonstrates a higher market value than current salary to justify an emergency retention pay adjustment

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by katastic on Monday October 09, 2017 @08:51PM (#15438547)
I've been told it's always good to have counter-offers to proof to your boss your worth X dollars to the industry.

OBVIOUSLY we're all talking about different corporate cultures and you have to play whatever strategy is best for your environment.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by kbart on Monday October 09, 2017 @08:42AM (#15433320)
I don't know many cases where you would be given 30-50% raise, unless you were junior or intern. Though such raise is common when switching jobs in early-mid career.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by foopod on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:42PM (#15429617)
> Best engineers are coin operated and problem focused I would say that the best engineers know their worth, but saying that money is all they care about is surely an exaggeration.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by fsloth on Monday October 09, 2017 @02:43AM (#15431952)
That goes without saying - if smart people want just to acquire wealth they will surely look for some other employment than engineering.

Engineering in the large is a profit generating endeavour. Therefore, when an engineer reviews his revenue stream, what he is doing is evaluating the worth of his contribution to society based on one heuristic variable.

Sure, it's never clear cut, but putting it as bluntly as I did underlines the fact that pecuniary compensation can be viewed as a form of just reward and not just profit seeking (which some consider immoral).

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by ugh123 on Saturday October 07, 2017 @06:59PM (#15426147)
Every situation is different.

Example: An employee has become bored in their current role, and a snoozing manager hasn't noticed in a while. If the employee hasn't been engaged by their manager then, sure, they'll look elsewhere. HR's (and the manager's manager) first question should be: have we offered this employee a different role outside of this project/team.

Not every employee who has given notice is completely "checked out". They may be frustrated in their current role where they might not have been given the right opportunities for more responsibility or higher profile projects. Asking the employee what their real issues are is the first step.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by humanrebar on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:34PM (#15426423)
For what it's worth, I can vouch for this situation happening to me. On a few occasions. In different organizations.

Other than the vague "Are years four through six here going to make me more valuable than years one through three somewhere else?", I would have been fine sticking around with a promotion, new technical opportunities, more strategic leeway, or even a big enough raise.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by KGIII on Sunday October 08, 2017 @03:42AM (#15427355)
My view has been prevent it in the first place. If my employee was seeking work elsewhere, then we have failed them. If you are unhappy then you should be in a work environment where you're able to address that successfully and in a mature manner. If your concerns aren't aired, they can't be addressed. Air them and we will do what we can to keep you from needing to move elsewhere.

Anything else means having failed the employee - with some exceptions. Some folks do have unreasonable requirements that will not be satisfied.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by humanrebar on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:22AM (#15428302)
I believe my managers in the roles I left had a similar perspective to what you're saying. For different reasons, the execution just wasn't there, however.

Usually it's because the organization didn't allow them the room to manage the way they wanted. Sometimes they just weren't allowed to provide the raise or promotion necessary. Sometimes there weren't roles for tackling the problems I wanted to tackle. More often, the managers were just too distracted and spread thin in time and/or political capital. They were pressured (or at least felt pressured) to say yes to things they shouldn't (over my concerns and objections) and didn't have time to do much more than keep chopping wood.

I'm not a shy person. I'll be clear and hopefully even handed about my concerns. But I won't throw tantrums, talk about people behind their backs, or make ultimatums. If, after a reasonable amount of time, my input isn't taken seriously, I'll have to find opportunities where I can contribute. Maybe on another team, maybe in another company. Otherwise I'm shortchanging my potential.

> Some folks do have unreasonable requirements that will not be satisfied.

I don't have unreasonable requirements, but good managers will be clear if they feel this way. It will save me time in the long run, at least.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by KGIII on Sunday October 08, 2017 @06:13PM (#15430295)
The company was mine and had slightly less than 250 employees. It is probably a bit different than what people experience today. It was also started in the early 90s.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by wolco on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:13AM (#15428264)
Do you automatically / randomly give raises that pushes there salary to match the job market?
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by KGIII on Sunday October 08, 2017 @06:27PM (#15430370)
There wasn't much of anything to compare with. Traffic modeling 'on a computer' didn't have (m)any domain experts, nor programmers with domain knowledge. So, training was key and something I felt strongly about.

I started employees at higher rates than senior traffic engineers make today. Pay also included bonuses and profit sharing, sort of. The profit sharing wasn't ever written into policy.

The benefits were prett good. I always tried to find a way to ensure any additional training/education goals were met. We'd still pay their partial salary while they attended, cover child care expenses, and things like that - if and where needed. It wasn't always domain related. I've paid for people to take culinary arts classes, albeit at night, just because they wanted to learn to cook better.

Err... It is slightly more involved than that and a post of its own, if you want me to write about that aspect. I'm willing to do so, but I strive to remain on topic.

As mentioned elsewhere, I had slightly less than 250 employees. I also never took any classes in management. So, I got away with things that would be laughed at today. Our head office had a small bar and pool table in the back, for example.

Anyhow, a programmer would have probably started at about $120k in the year 2000. That is unadjusted. Not having taken any management classes, I realized that individual salaries were paltry compared to other fees, I paid $12k per month just for a print room.

I also realized it wasn't my money paying for it. I kept the business' funds separate from my own and drew down a salary like everyone else. My clients paid our salaries. If I had higher salaries, my rates would adjust to suit.

If you're curious, I actually paid myself a smaller salary than some employees got paid. I'd hired them to do complicated things that I could not do. I paid them accordingly.

It was rather unorthodox. The company was sold and the sake was finalized in 2007. The now-parent company is public so it has SEC filings. I suspect I've given out enough information to figure out the name, but I'll let you sleuth or not. I kind of enjoy not being known as 'that guy' and having to meet expectations.

Related: I am still mulling over the idea of writing a book, but I am not really a good writer. So, it's a bit of a toss-up.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by le-mark on Monday October 09, 2017 @09:39AM (#15433654)
I'd suggest writing a book, or a set of anonymized blog posts if you want to remain unknown. It's easier than piecing together from your comment history :P
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by wpietri on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:09PM (#15426356)
I'm definitely of that school of thought. I think if you're waiting to the point of a counteroffer to retain talent, you've already lost.

I think part of my job as a manager is to make sure that everybody is paid fairly all the time. For me that means benchmarking the salary structure to peer companies, a good career ladder, regular performance reviews, etc.

If one of my employees came to me and said, "A friend at company X said I could make $Y if I moved there", I'd definitely use that data to make sure our total package was fair. Hopefully we'd find we were already doing things well, but if not, I could easily see that research resulting in raises.

On the other hand, if somebody comes to me and says, "I already have an offer in hand from place X for $Y because I've been secretly job hunting for the last month," then I'd be very unlikely to counteroffer with more money. I'd certainly want to talk about why they were unhappy enough to start job hunting. Maybe there's a problem we weren't aware of or taking seriously enough. (And also I'd want to investigate how we hadn't discovered the problem until it was big enough they wanted to quit.) If we can solve that problem for them (and hopefully for other people, we should.

But if it's only a question of money when I think our pay is fair, then I wouldn't counter. One, I don't think money keeps anybody anywhere for long, so I'd expect the counter to be a bandaid. Two, either I have to change the whole salary structure to match or I've just made things less fair. That penalizes people who aren't as money-focused. Three, there are often reasons other places pay more on a cash basis. If somebody values cash more than other things I like to provide (e.g., working with good people, good work-life balance, more time available for learning, not having to clean up giant messes), then maybe they will be happier elsewhere.

And really, I'm fine with that. If somebody working for me would really be happier elsewhere, I'd rather help them find that next job. And if they won't be happier elsewhere but need to find that out for themselves, I'd rather have them feel welcome to come back.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by humanrebar on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:44PM (#15426443)
> ...part of my job as a manager is to make sure that everybody is paid fairly all the time

I like managers that set up their team for big wins and them make sure they are treated accordingly, both humane work/life balance and with excellent pay. "Fair" pay is fine, but I'm striving to provide an exceptional value. So I think fair pay if I achieve that goal doesn't look like "competitive" or "market rate".

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by wpietri on Sunday October 08, 2017 @12:06AM (#15426932)
It seems like we agree. If your provide exceptional value and the pay matches, that sounds fair to me. If you are the kind of person who is in high demand such that employers will pay more, then it sounds to me like you have a higher market rate.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by thisone on Sunday October 08, 2017 @08:07AM (#15427908)
your wording is a bit odd to me.

If you strive to 'provide exceptional value', but want to be compensated highly, then the you are not providing exceptional value. Perhaps it should be 'commensurate value'

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by humanrebar on Sunday October 08, 2017 @10:04AM (#15428239)
Something can have a higher sticker price but be more than worth it. That's a "value proposition".
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by noitsnot on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:33PM (#15426420)
What, like a fake family /friendship so you can undercut salary? I don't do work for hugs, bro. That doesn't put food on the table or pay bills.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by strken on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:33PM (#15426422)
If "good work/life balance" means working 40 hour weeks instead of 80 hour weeks, then it's far more valuable than a beer fridge and a yearly snow trip.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by wpietri on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:41PM (#15426439)
I can see why you wouldn't post this under your own name. Did you get all your feels out? Ready to have a real discussion? If so, let's go. (If not, go back and yell at whoever actually hurt you, because it wasn't me.)

My dad and stepmother are now-retired developers. I still identify as one, although mostly I manage now, as it has become more important to me to create a context where good work can be done than to do the work directly. I still try to write at least a little code every day, as I love it. So yeah, I appreciate what engineers do. However.

Let's do a thought experiment. Imagine there are only two companies: a good one and a shitty one. At the good one, everybody goes home on time. The code is pretty clean. The people are friendly and supportive. They build good things as part of making happy customers. At the shitty one, though, it's the opposite. It was founded by exploitative dicks. They want everybody to work all the time. They're always rushing, so there's high tech debt and everything's buggy. That means lots of screwed-up schedules and early-morning phone calls to fix production issues. And plenty of shouting and blaming, of course.

Now ask yourself: which company will pay more? Answer: the shitty one. Because if the salary is the same, rational actors will take the pleasant job with the nice people. The shitty company has to pay more.

Years ago I worked for financial traders. I made very good money. I also worked long enough hours that I sometimes slept on the office couch. Too often, I got screamed at by traders, because they liked yelling at people. The work was meaningless; we were just trying to carve off a slight of economic value that other people created. Eventually the work burned me out. It took me a long time to recover.

In the ensuing years I've worked at a variety of places, big and small, for-profit and non-, competent and incompetent. I have learned that there are many more important things to me than money. It's important to me that the salary be fair, both in a mark-to-market and in a results-of-productivity-fairly-allocated way. But beyond that, I care about other things. And so I try to create contexts where I and others can get those things.

If you would rather maximize your income, that is totally fine by me. People want different things. But just because you don't care about work-life balance doesn't mean that the people who do are idiots.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by humanrebar on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:50PM (#15426459)
You're right, but only because you set up a false dichotomy. I think healthy teamwork, sustainable lifestyles, and good pay are all possible. If you only make good money by being a jerk, then there's something messed up about the market or business plan, which seems like a recipe for worse compensation, not better.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by wpietri on Sunday October 08, 2017 @12:02AM (#15426921)
I too believe those things are achievable, and I said repeatedly that fair pay is important to me.

However, terrible places that stay in business are often compelled to pay more. Sometimes they can do that because they exploit their customers. Sometimes it's because they can dump negative externalities on others. Sometimes it's because they cut corners. Sometimes the work is just soulless and extractive.

And sometimes it's just because they are very stingy with non-cash benefits. E.g., I was just talking to someone who had taken 5 months of paternity leave. I have friends who will take 4-6 weeks of vacation per year. I know other people who get a lot of support for education, for speaking at conferences, for learning.

If a company does more of the bad stuff and little or none of the good stuff, they can afford to offer higher salaries. And that's fine. If somebody wants to work at a place like that, godspeed.

As a perhaps more obvious example, consider some equally smart but differently trained people: lawyers. I have friends who joined soulless corporate firms, worked 100-hour weeks for years, and now are doing very well financially. Some started their own small practices doing the kind of law that interested them; they make decent money. Others do public service law for nonprofits, helping people who can't afford to pay lawyers; they make yet less. All of these are reasonable paths, but they pay very differently. If one of the non-profit lawyers gets an offer from a giant law firm, their current employer will not try to match that. Everybody understands that.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by rbrcurtis on Saturday October 07, 2017 @08:58PM (#15426485)
Totally agree with this.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by analog31 on Saturday October 07, 2017 @06:08PM (#15425953)
Something I've wondered is whether this is basically a bluffing tactic: If an employee is persuaded that there will be no counteroffer, then it's more of an emotional hurdle to start the job search.

On the flip side, I was hired during a hiring freeze.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by platz on Saturday October 07, 2017 @06:55PM (#15426125)
It would only be a bluff if your initial threat to take another offer was a bluff, which would change the situation entirely
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by w_t_payne on Sunday October 08, 2017 @05:56AM (#15427636)
I would never ever counteroffer. To do so would crack Pandora's box wide open.

First of all, it is simply not a game that I am willing to play.

Secondly, the other team members will know about it (eventually) and will (eventually) try to do the same thing.

Overall, it would be detrimental to team cohesion and would undermine the culture that I want to build:- One that is focused entirely on solving the problem in front of us.

If a member of my team needed a pay rise (i.e. if they were expecting a child) then I would work energetically to represent them within the organisation to make sure that they get what they need -- but for their part I would expect them to interact with me honestly and not play silly games.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by gaius on Sunday October 08, 2017 @07:01AM (#15427762)
If a member of my team needed a pay rise (i.e. if they were expecting a child)

Wow, isn't that massively discriminatory? Raises and contributions should be merit- or contribution-based, no more and no less.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by kixiQu on Sunday October 08, 2017 @01:17PM (#15429027)
Yeah, I'm trying to read it as "if a member of my team came to me with a new ambition to do what it takes to up their comp (for whatever reason) I'd work with them to expand their role in the org" but... it should not be a manager's job to view me taking care of my parents differently from Coworker X buying anime figurines if Coworker X and I are in the same role having the same success.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by pertymcpert on Sunday October 08, 2017 @08:18AM (#15427935)
It's not silly games. It's a business transaction, they're negotiating. I think it's fair to not counter offer for reasons stated elsewhere in this thread but you can't accuse people of playing games when this is such an important part of our lives. So much is dependent on money, to not negotiate with other offers is foolish when the moment a company decides that an employee is less valuable than their cost they're out the door.
Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by rdtsc on Sunday October 08, 2017 @08:04AM (#15427897)
Would you give them a 30%-40% raise? That's what people are often getting when they switch jobs.

Another point is some might feel if they have to ask for a raise, the company has failed them already, they work should have been noticed by then.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by muzani on Sunday October 08, 2017 @12:16AM (#15426954)
Agreed. Quitting your job is like a relationship break up.

Talking someone into staying might just get them to say yes, to be nice, then just change their mind and not show up some day.

Re:Ask HN: How common is a counteroffer for developers who g... by 0xbear on Sunday October 08, 2017 @02:11AM (#15427170)
In a small company, maybe. In a large one, not at all. Get that counter, negotiate a promo, change teams 6 months later. Everyone is happy.