Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by erdbeerkuchen on Saturday October 07, 2017 @12:10PM
(#15424309)
What was the percentage of Jewish applicants passing these examinations despite all these efforts?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by lohankin on Saturday October 07, 2017 @01:16PM
(#15424636)
The target acceptance rate was rumored to be 2% - which roughly corresponded to the percentage of Jewish population in USSR.
I was one of those Jewish applicants in 1973 :)
Exam was conducted in a separate room. When in doubt, the criteria for identifying Jews among all applicants was funny (in retrospect): they tried to guess by the last name. But some names are more "typical" than others, so the criteria was not 100% accurate. They preferred to err on the side of caution, and some perfectly Russian people were put in the same exam room with the Jews. This is my recollection.
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by forapurpose on Saturday October 07, 2017 @03:20PM
(#15425244)
> they tried to guess by the last name
You'll find this interesting:
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by lohankin on Saturday October 07, 2017 @06:21PM
(#15426020)
Those cases were probably quite common. From wikipedia article about Glenn Gould, the great Canadian pianist:
"The family's surname was changed to Gould informally around 1939 in order to avoid being mistaken for Jewish, given the prevailing anti-Semitism of prewar Toronto and the Gold surname's Jewish association"
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by sidlls on Saturday October 07, 2017 @12:34PM
(#15424424)
I imagine quite small, if any were allowed to. Tests like these usually also have a hidden rubric such that the test taker never quite manages to reach the minimum passing grade. It's unlikely anybody with the education of a high-schooler (even a fairly advanced one) would be able to solve very many of these problems in a typical allotment of time for a test. They're not sophisticated problems, in the sense that relatively basic mathematical principles can be used to solve most (or all) of them, but they're really quite complicated problems for a test. I mean "complicated" in the sense that they require a fair bit of rather tedious busy work to arrive at a solution.
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by dia80 on Saturday October 07, 2017 @12:17PM
(#15424341)
I recall reading elsewhere it was zero, they simply weren't allowed to admit Jewish students and these problems were just to try and cover up the discrimination.
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by wolf550e on Saturday October 07, 2017 @01:04PM
(#15424587)
There was a quota, like in the US in the 1930s. In the USSR, about 2% of population was Jews, so university was allowed to admit 2% Jews every year. But because of culture of education and desire to avoid conscription to Red Army[1] and non-uniform population density, it was very difficult for Jews to get admitted in the good universities in Moscow and Leningrad (the two largest cities with most prestigious universities).
1 - The Soviet military was bad for everyone, but Jews tended to get hurt more. Students accepted by a university would not be conscripted and would be listed as reserve officers, having never spent time in uniform
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by forapurpose on Saturday October 07, 2017 @02:43PM
(#15425039)
> The Soviet military was bad for everyone, but Jews tended to get hurt more.
I know one Jewish man from the USSR, now deceased, who told me he emigrated from the USSR to avoid conscription; he said that the military at times used Jewish soldiers as cannon fodder: They were sent to the front without arms to draw and consume enemy fire.
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by betaby on Saturday October 07, 2017 @12:41PM
(#15424460)
Not true at all.
How that explain then world known physicists and mathematicians from USSR with Jewish names?
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by lohankin on Saturday October 07, 2017 @01:24PM
(#15424672)
If not for this quota, you would have much greater number of "known physicists and mathematicians from USSR with Jewish names" LOL
In some places (Moscow University math dep-t) the target was about 2%, but I heard some technical schools didn't accept anyone (after Natan Scharansky affair. Long story...)
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by dia80 on Saturday October 07, 2017 @04:07PM
(#15425435)
I recall it was Moscow state university they wouldn't admit any, other schools would
Re:These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people fro...
by garrybelka on Saturday October 07, 2017 @12:33PM
(#15424420)
Maybe one or several guys a year - winners of international math olympiads or folks on a similar level.
E.g.,
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maxim_Kontsevich