Re:Proton-size puzzle deepens
by monochromatic on Friday October 06, 2017 @08:53PM
(#15421596)
Why would the error be linear in the mass of the electron or muon? I mean, maybe it is... but itβs not at all obvious to me why that would be so.
They didn't say the error was linear in the mass, only that it was functionally dependent on the mass in some manner.
I don't understand this question. Why would the muon's mass change the error rate?
because the imputed 'radius' of the proton in normal matter is a function of its interactions with electrons in orbit and its own properties. If you replace an electron with a Muon which orbits but is 400x more massive, then some element of distortion has to come into play. Its radii is now a function of its innate properties and an orbiting body 400x more massive than normal.
Therefore, I posit (plausibly wrongly btw, I am not a physicist)_ that there is some measurement inaccuracy which stems from this, which is a function of this 400x size difference.
That might have made sense up until this latest measurement. The latest measurement found a smaller size for the proton in ordinary hydrogen, consistent with the previous smaller measurement for muonic hydrogen.
Radius being understood to be somewhat metaphorical here.