Re:The Last Invention of Man
by saulrh on Friday October 06, 2017 @07:59PM
(#15421356)
You're betting everything on vacuous what-ifs. I mean, let's turn this around:
With no way to define intelligence (except by pointing to ourselves), we don't even know if we're good at it. For all we know human intelligence is a dead end. Maybe any entity that is not a product of evolution, free of genetic detritus that becomes maladaptive around advanced technology, will outstrip human civilization like human civilization outstripped evolution.
I don't doubt the book is full of entertaining soundbytes, but given these two quotes I am unconvinced that it is any more than entertainment.
With no way to define intelligence (except by pointing to ourselves), we don't even know if we're good at it. For all we know human intelligence is a dead end. Maybe any entity that is not a product of evolution, free of genetic detritus that becomes maladaptive around advanced technology, will outstrip human civilization like human civilization outstripped evolution.
I don't doubt the book is full of entertaining soundbytes, but given these two quotes I am unconvinced that it is any more than entertainment.