If the proton and muon sizes were different [...]
They are different, in fact the muon is believed to be a point particle and not to have any internal structure like, for example, the proton. Nonetheless one can assign a non-zero radius to the muon in specific contexts due to its interaction with the vacuum.
If the proton and muon sizes were different, then a bunch of physicists would be chomping away at being able to replace the Standard Model and get the Nobel Prize.
As it stands, it looks like there's a question of why the old measurements were off, and that's about it.