Re:Joining Google to better explain search
by amoorthy on Friday October 06, 2017 @08:32PM
(#15421525)
We built a Chrome extension to help users evaluate the quality of an article's citations and suggest better alternatives. This is Beta; the algorithm will soon go beyond citations and our recommendations will become more frequent. But I'd be grateful for any feedback you all have if you take a look. Thank you.
https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/civikowl/clbbiejji...
Re:Joining Google to better explain search
by MBCook on Friday October 06, 2017 @06:28PM
(#15420935)
I agree.
But given the position they hold I think they need to develop this skill.
It’s very clear that ‘throw an algorithm up without thinking of abuse/negative consequences and fix it later’ works terribly.
Re:Joining Google to better explain search
by dragonwriter on Saturday October 07, 2017 @01:03AM
(#15422354)
I'd rather Google provide a framework to integrate third-party ratings; we don't need a monopoly arbiter of online truth that's also a monopoly search provider.
Google does lots of things I like, but I see close to zero evidence that they have developed the competency to act as an arbiter on any of veracity, reliability, or trustworthiness of news articles (or even less-timely information on the web.)
Relevance and my likelihood to be interested, yes. But those other things...no.
And that's even aside from the question of whether Google using its dominant search position to inject editorial commentary on search results is a good thing or, in the long term, a bigger threat than the one it would be addressing.