Modern MySQL is extremely well suited for data that cannot be lost - as is I'm sure, Postgres.
That said, if you're pre 5.6, I _strongly_ suggest upgrading to 5.6 or all the way to MariaDB 10. The performance, safety, stability, etc have skyrocketed in recent years.
See STRICT_ALL_TABLES / https://mariadb.com/kb/en/library/sql-mode/
Modern MySQL is extremely well suited for data that cannot be lost - as is I'm sure, Postgres.
That said, if you're pre 5.6, I _strongly_ suggest upgrading to 5.6 or all the way to MariaDB 10. The performance, safety, stability, etc have skyrocketed in recent years.