News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why was my first question killed? by Robin_Message on Friday July 23, 2010 @09:39AM (#1541111)
Flagging is not negative karma, it is marking something as spam. You don't see a flag link because you don't have enough karma.

As to your post, a new version of PostGres is interesting to many people. Release of open source P2P project - not so much. However, your post is actually a blog post that has some interesting info in, so I'd suggest with a better title your post would have appeared much less spammy and encouraged more clicks (e.g. "As of today, JXTA 2.6 is a mature library for P2P in Java". But not that. Just like that. Not that.)

As to transparency, no-one sees how many flags a post has (except pg I guess and some automated algorithm.) People must simply make an honest assessment themselves if they think a post is off-topic/spam. By not showing the number of flags pile-on effects are avoided. Multiple flags are required to kill a post, so it would have to be a large, shady conspiracy to bury your P2P software - perhaps the flags came from riaa1 through riaa10!

Re:Ask HN: Why was my first question killed? by JVerstry on Friday July 23, 2010 @09:51AM (#1541136)
Ok, I get your suggestion about title. You say my post has interesting info.

Problem is, I still don't know whether people considered it a spam or whether there has been a glitch last week (I mean, why hasn't it been displayed on the main page?).

I have no problem if some people found it a spam, but I think I have a right to know then. Isn't it a legitimate request? There must be a possibility to display that info to the poster only?

P.S.: I am adding my link here again so people can judge whether it is spam:

http://adamman71.blogspot.com/2010/07/jxtajxse-26-is-out_433...

I'd love to have people's opinion. Thanks !!!