News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Die young, live fast: The evolution of an underclass by yummyfajitas on Friday July 23, 2010 @09:20AM (#1541069)
Why do you believe human experience is not amenable to reason and analysis by other humans, but quantum physics is? Shouldn't it be easier to reason about the familiar than the unfamiliar?

In any case, I could make the same argument about different types of human experience, and you'd still reject it. Do you believe that only devout muslims can rationally opine on honor killings, or that only racists can discuss racism?

Re:Die young, live fast: The evolution of an underclass by rdtsc on Friday July 23, 2010 @11:18AM (#1541397)
It is amenable to reason but only up to a limit. Certainly someone who had the experienced would be more qualified to reason about it.

I would say that is even true for racism and honor killings. Someone who grew up in a muslem country or in the deep south in US will definetly understand better the underlying causes for rampant racism or why honor killings happen.

As for quantum physics, I would take someone's word if I believed they could experience it. I don't think any one can, so that's why anyone that can do the maths is just as good.