News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by frou_dh on Thursday October 05, 2017 @10:10AM (#15409292)
It’s odd to talk about “needs” like this. iPhones don’t “need” the Secure Enclave either, but never the less it’s great that they have it.

It’s some kind of snobbery to advocate that good technology should be held back until non-enterprise plebs demonstrate that they are deserving of it.

Just give everyone the good technology as much as is possible. Who’s it hurting if some subjectively underutilise it?

Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by tokenizerrr on Thursday October 05, 2017 @10:53AM (#15409623)
> Just give everyone the good technology as much as is possible. Who’s it hurting if some subjectively underutilise it?

Everyone who buys the product and doesn't require the technology, because they'll be spending more money on something they don't need or use.

Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by LeifCarrotson on Thursday October 05, 2017 @12:08PM (#15410276)
If ECC was the normal product that went into everything, and someone invented "unverified" RAM to get a tiny speed boost and slightly decreased cost, how much do you think the actual price difference would be? I expect it would be tiny.

It's a political decision by Intel to make ECC an Xeon-only product which has resulted in the vast majority of the price difference. The silicon die area required for it really doesn't cost that much more - often, the area is present on the consumer dies but just disabled so they can charge a lot more to the enterprise customers who actually require it. And political decisions like that make a lot of HN users unhappy.

As Joel Spolsky said in https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-...:

> Working my way backwards, this business about segmenting? It pisses the heck off of people. People want to feel they’re paying a fair price.... And God help you if an A-list blogger finds out that your premium printer is identical to the cheap printer, with the speed inhibitor turned off.

Everyone knows that ECC parts are nearly identical to the cheap parts, with the ECC module turned off. But there's no boycott, because there are (were?) no other options, like there might be for a printer company. ECC segmentation is just something everyone knows and resents.

Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by tokenizerrr on Friday October 06, 2017 @08:00AM (#15416063)
I'm responding to the generalization in the previous comment, I don't specifically agree about ECC.
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by frou_dh on Thursday October 05, 2017 @11:08AM (#15409754)
How does someone “not use” ECC RAM when their computer contains it?

Computer reliability should be a rising tide. Up-and-to-the-right is the goal.