News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by KekDemaga on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:28AM (#15408575)
28 cores sure, but they run a base frequency of 2.50GHz. For $1469 you can have the i9-7940X 14 cores at 3.1GHz probably more suitable for a workstation.
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by SSLy on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:31AM (#15408592)
No ECC support
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by KekDemaga on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:34AM (#15408604)
I'd go for the Threadripper 1950X if that is a requirement then 16 cores, 3.4 GHz, ECC support all for under $1000. Intel doesn't really have anything that meets those requirements at a reasonable price.
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by really_operator on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:48AM (#15408681)
I thought he said if money was no object...
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by mtgx on Thursday October 05, 2017 @10:09AM (#15409276)
Then his choice is $13,000 vs $1,000.

Money may not be an object, but choosing the first option seems a little stupid. Even rich people don't throw away money like that, because if they did, they probably wouldn't have gotten rich in the first place.

Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by KekDemaga on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:57AM (#15408736)
It depends on the workload but for most cases those extra cores will just sit idle (that Intel is for things like webservers serving many concurrent requests), for most general workstation tasks you'll get better performance from the AMD offering. It's sort of like buying a half million dollar tractor trailer to go fast instead of a hundred thousand dollar sports car.
Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by Coding_Cat on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:56AM (#15408730)
28 cores @ 2.5 GHz = 70 GHz Cores, 14 cores @ 3.1 GHz = 43.4 GHz cores.

So the total performance (to first order) is almost twice as good for the 28 core part. Sure you need to use all cores for that comparison to hold, but usually software either scales up to 8 cores or less or it scales up to N cores.

Re:Best CPUs for Workstations: 2017 by alkonaut on Thursday October 05, 2017 @09:15AM (#15408861)
This gets muddied by the use of boost clocks, and this part does 3.8Ghz in that mode. What would be nice to see is a processor aimed at long stretches of interactive use with few cores (1-4) and then long stretches of offline uses with many cores (16-32 cores).

A lot of "workstation" use is long stretches of interactive use on a few cores followed by periods of offline use (NN training, Graphical rendering, Code compilation/testing etc). The boost clocks on these higher end cpu's should really be able to go even higher, even if it means the base clocks would have to go down somewhat. I'd rather have a 28core CPU where it runs either 20 cores entirely OFF and the rest at 4.5Ghz, than one where it runs at 2.5-3.8Ghz.