Re:Useful GCC warning options not enabled by -Wall -Wextra
by asveikau on Thursday October 05, 2017 @12:10AM
(#15406643)
I think you guys are missing something in my perplexed state at this construct. I'm not saying it out of lack of experience or because I disbelieve in the "going out of my way to make things more maintainable though verbosity" aspect. It's just that many times in practice I have rarely seen an honest switch statement that really needs case labels for all possible values. Much more common in my experience, 1 or more cases are no-ops. I think it's pointless to list out the no-ops, but I've seen people advocate just that.
There are exceptions to this "some cases are no-ops" thing. But I think it's the minority of switches I've seen.
From that perspective it does seem like the coding police angle. It's reminiscent of certain things in Java, like making a bunch of implicit conversions into errors, or C#, which forbids implicit fall-through on a switch. Those too are for safety and maintainability. They also make a lot of constructs more ugly. My question is: is it worth it? In this case (unintended pun) I don't think so.
Re:Useful GCC warning options not enabled by -Wall -Wextra
by Sean1708 on Thursday October 05, 2017 @08:09AM
(#15408450)
Really? I've literally never written (or at least I don't ever remember writing) a case statement without either specifying every possible value or adding a meaningful default case.
This.
And not necessarily yourself, but whomever maintains the software after you.
Of course this doesn't prevent someone from adding a "default" label in some future iteration.