Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ...
by xiaoma on Friday July 23, 2010 @07:31AM
(#1540903)
I doubt anybody has subjected themselves to a rigorous study on the subject. What the people I know have done is this: try the handwriting recognition for a few days, go back to zhuyin or maybe wubi for a day or two and then go back to handwriting because they believe it's faster based on their own experience.
Non-standard writing and simplifications are recognized in many cases. It's far from perfect; it's just a bit faster and more convenient than their old phones.
Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ...
by Jd on Friday July 23, 2010 @11:30PM
(#1543034)
Apples and oranges. I believe the discussion was of standard input systems (i.e. keyboards) not iPhone keyboards for which I can easily believe that handwriting outperforms pinyin and/or wubi.
P.S. This reminds me of the days in the 1980s when I had to translate handwritten manuscripts by magazine reporters in Chinese into English. There is a lot of nonstandard handwriting in the Chinese-speaking world, as I discovered when I would ask colleagues to read one another's handwriting to get a reality check on how I read it.