News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple and Qualcomm’s Billion-Dollar War Over an $18 Part by MBCook on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @01:31PM (#15402251)
App developers agreed to the 30%. Qualcomm agreed to FRAND pricing.

But that’s not what they’re charging Apple. They broke an agreement.

What Apple is doing doesn’t violate an agreement, whatever you think of it.

Re:Apple and Qualcomm’s Billion-Dollar War Over an $18 Part by tooltalk on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:11PM (#15402752)
and Apple agreed to pay Qualcomm's FRAND rates, didn't it? Like Apple's 30% cut known to the public, Qualcomm's FRAND licensing rates are published time to time and Apple agreed to abide by it.

Apple pays according to the article about $10 per device, or 1.33% of the retail price. This is far below what Qualcomm is charging, 3% to 5%, and what most handset makers pay. Further the royalty Apple pays (indirectly) is based on Apple's manufacturer's build cost, not retail cost.

Re:Apple and Qualcomm’s Billion-Dollar War Over an $18 Part by atka on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:26PM (#15402957)
And FRAND doesn't mean anything. It just means fair reasonable and non discrimatory. If Qualcomm charges everyone the same then how is this not met.
Re:Apple and Qualcomm’s Billion-Dollar War Over an $18 Part by MBCook on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:32PM (#15404903)
Just because they charge everyone the same thing doesn’t make it fair or reasonable.

What if they sold their chip for $10 and sold licenses to the necessary patents for $100/unit?

That’s not fair or reasonable. It’s one kind of situation FRAND was designed to prevent.