Re:Apple and Qualcomm’s Billion-Dollar War Over an $18 Part
by tooltalk on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:11PM
(#15402752)
and Apple agreed to pay Qualcomm's FRAND rates, didn't it? Like Apple's 30% cut known to the public, Qualcomm's FRAND licensing rates are published time to time and Apple agreed to abide by it.
Apple pays according to the article about $10 per device, or 1.33% of the retail price. This is far below what Qualcomm is charging, 3% to 5%, and what most handset makers pay. Further the royalty Apple pays (indirectly) is based on Apple's manufacturer's build cost, not retail cost.
Re:Apple and Qualcomm’s Billion-Dollar War Over an $18 Part
by atka on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:26PM
(#15402957)
And FRAND doesn't mean anything. It just means fair reasonable and non discrimatory. If Qualcomm charges everyone the same then how is this not met.
Re:Apple and Qualcomm’s Billion-Dollar War Over an $18 Part
by MBCook on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:32PM
(#15404903)
Just because they charge everyone the same thing doesn’t make it fair or reasonable.
What if they sold their chip for $10 and sold licenses to the necessary patents for $100/unit?
That’s not fair or reasonable. It’s one kind of situation FRAND was designed to prevent.
But that’s not what they’re charging Apple. They broke an agreement.
What Apple is doing doesn’t violate an agreement, whatever you think of it.