In the portrait pic of the girl, the difference between the Pixel 2 [1] and the iPhone 8 [2] is night and day, with the Pixel 2 looking like shit. She so pale, and the fake bokeh looks like a 5 year old smearing all over, it's simply not pleasant to look at.
And the whole push on adding the fake bokeh """scores""" to justify changing the scores so every fucking newly released device gets the highest score is stupid. Thanks for scoring the bokeh, if I had really wanted bokeh, I would have pulled out my bulky mirrorless camera.
I bet when a new phone comes out and they pay the DxO guy enough, they will add a dog nose filter score to make the new camera score the highest.
1: A https://cdn.dxomark.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/ref1_Boke...
B https://cdn.dxomark.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/ref2_Lowl...
2: A https://cdn.dxomark.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/ref1_Boke...
B https://cdn.dxomark.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/ref2_Lowl...
If you compare the right eyebrow, you will see that [1] have more details, than [2]
Remember, the picture is always a depiction of what our eyes see, and that our eyes see is only a part of the reality. My eyes don't see bokehs. My eyes don't focus the same way the camera does. My eyes don't see in 3500K or 6500K or whatever the hell that is. My eyes don't care how many strands of hair there are in her eyebrows and how detailed they are. My eyes don't see in black and white, either. Yet those are what you see in pictures. Focusing on the little detail "accuracy" and forget what it really matters at the end is dangerous.
Another one of your posts, talking about the white temperature, etc, is just surreal, and I dare you say that you are utterly clueless on this subject.
I mean the fact they sell cameras alone means they’re not unbiased.
https://daringfireball.net/linked/2017/09/22/dxo-ratings-are...
Wait for real camera reviews.
Measuring the technical capabilities of an imaging device is patently obvious and justifiable. From dynamic range to optical and electronic resolution, noise at different light levels, etc. You can question their methodology, but saying that it "doesn't measure anything" is nonsense, and citing a guy who laughably claims that you can't measure the "art" is uproarious.
Gruber has less than zero legitimacy in this discussion, and his sole motivating intention is defend Apple in all facets.
Most DSLR reviews have a consistent scene that pushes the envelope of what a sensor can capture, and all cameras are benchmarked against that scene. Here's an example: https://www.dpreview.com/reviews/nikon-d7500-review-speed-an...
And I'm not "defensive" of DXO scores any more than I'm defensive of dpreview. DXO analyzes a variety of real world technical capabilities of imaging systems -- most certainly in an imperfect way and needing more rigor -- but to call it "horseshit", or to ridiculously claim that it measures nothing, is specious.
Snake oil is what that number is.
I agree completely. DPreview and other sites do that.
> but saying that it "doesn't measure anything" is nonsense
Then please tell me what that one final number measures. How do they get to it? It doesn’t seem objective at all.
Other camera review sites give a bunch of objective measurements then a subjective opinion about how the camera related to others.
DXO wants you to think their arbitrary number is scientifically rigorous.
> and citing a guy who laughably claims that you can't measure the "art" is uproarious.
Are you claiming you can measure art? That’s what DXO seems to do. Having a single number final score means that if camera A had a higher score than B then it must take objectively better pictures.
Or we have to admit their score is subjective.
> Gruber has less than zero legitimacy in this discussion
Why?
> and his sole motivating intention is defend Apple in all facets.
He’s complaining that the iPhone had the highest score ever. If you were right he would be writing about how DXO said it was the best camera ever, not that DXO is a sham.
If you can’t look past Gruber’s byline I imagine there are other articles online about DXO and their questionable practices. I’ve seen others before, this was the first Google turned up.
Because Gruber is a biased individual whose professional existence is to pander to a narrow crowd. He has nothing broadly interesting to say about cross-cutting concerns.
"He’s complaining that the iPhone had the highest score ever."
He previously dismissed DXO when the iPhone was beat. Now he wants to simultaneously crow about the iPhone taking the victory while claiming that he totally doesn't care about it anyways. People buy this teenager level nonsense?
"Are you claiming you can measure art?"
This is absurd. DXO is a broad, generalist, imperfect measure of imaging devices, and paradoxically there is broad agreement that the devices that do really well generally are capable of the best photos.
But you can take a great photo with a pinhole camera, from an artistic perspective. Does this make a pinhole camera the best? That is nonsensical.
Don't believe DXO. Don't believe Consumer Reports. Don't believe metacritic or star reviews or RT or whatever. But to claim it measures nothing, or to cite some biased player, is not credible.
He wasn’t crowing about it. He was complaining people were taking about DXO scores at all because they’re a sham.
The dual pixel thing sounds a little iffy to me in that I wonder if it can really duplicate the portrait mode of the iPhone.
I’ll be very interested to see REAL reviews.
DXO’s numbers mean as much as a five star system. They’re not quantitative but want to be treated like they are.