News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by harisenbon on Thursday July 22, 2010 @10:49PM (#1540202)
I find it interesting that you say that each character represents a sound in western language, while not in Japanese or Chinese.

In Japanese こ can only be pronounced one way.

In Chinese (I believe) 子 can only be pronounced one way. It also has an associated meaning which is handy for learning new words.

In english, what sound does C make? ex) Chair Care cycle

Why can I pronounce Ghoti as 'Fish'?

Read <-- How do you pronounce this? Is it Red or Reed?

I actually find the looseness of English spelling to be much more of a hardship than learning a number of different pronunciations.

Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by derefr on Thursday July 22, 2010 @11:14PM (#1540226)
English is a bad example of a phonetic language. I prefer Latin: everything has one pronunciation (at least, when rendered in the Greek alphabet), and character-strings act as combining forms for words just as characters do in ideographic languages ("electro-" works in all the same situations that "電-" does.)
Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by zavulon on Thursday July 22, 2010 @11:09PM (#1540221)
I don't speak Chinese or Japanese, but people that do told me that there are more than five ways to pronounce "yi", they all mean different things, but they're all transliterated to English in the same way.

However, that's not what I meant. I meant to say as far as ease of transcribing spoken word onto paper, alphabet system is fundamentally easier, because you only have to remember 25-45 (approximately) number of characters. While in hieroglyphics, the number is much much larger.

Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by w1ntermute on Friday July 23, 2010 @12:37AM (#1540375)
I don't speak Chinese or Japanese, but people that do told me that there are more than five ways to pronounce "yi", they all mean different things, but they're all transliterated to English in the same way.

That's because Chinese is tonal. There are 5 different tones in Standard Mandarin. When transliterating Chinese to the English alphabet, there is no way to write the tone, so you introduce ambiguity that wasn't officially present.

Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by w1ntermute on Friday July 23, 2010 @12:39AM (#1540378)
I find it funny that you bring this up. How many ways can 二 be pronounced in Japanese?
Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by harisenbon on Friday July 23, 2010 @01:27AM (#1540440)
That'll teach me to omit details for simplicity. ;)

Kanji is an exception in Japanese because it was forcibly shoe-horned into the language. (Granted, Kanji came before kana, but as far as 'purely Japanese' scripts I think that kana takes precedence). Thus it really doesn't fit well with the Japanese pronunciations because sometimes it was brought in for meaning (火山 vs 火) without any care for how it was pronounced -- either forcing the pronunciation to conform to the original Japanese word, or creating a new word from the Chinese.

Also the fact that Kanji entered japan at different points in history means that there were different interpretations of how the kanji should be used. (I see something similar with katakana -- you can generally tell the timeframe in which the word entered the Japanese language depending on whether the word is based on the English spelling, or the English pronunciation. Or is even from another language such a Portuguese or German)

:: End Sidebar ::

Not that I think that Japanese is a great example of a "logical language." But one of the things I always liked about Japanese is the fact that (with a few exceptions) the kana can only be pronounced one way.

Btw, as I'm sure you know the pronunciations for 二 is に. But when you combine it as part of a word can also be pronounced ふた、ふ、ふう or じ

Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by w1ntermute on Friday July 23, 2010 @01:44AM (#1540465)
Kanji is an exception in Japanese because it was forcibly shoe-horned into the language.

Much like how the English alphabet ultimately originates from Egyptian hieroglyphs, and was forcibly shoe-horned into the language by the Romans as they spread Christianity across Europe.

But one of the things I always liked about Japanese is the fact that (with a few exceptions) the kana can only be pronounced one way.

Well, it does omit pitch accent. Reminds me of how my Japanese professor mentioned that she went almost a decade without realizing that in the こ-, そ-, あ-, ど- series, ど- involves a decrease in pitch, whereas the others involve an increase. Something that would be very useful to include in the orthography ;/

Btw, as I'm sure you know the pronunciations for 二 is に. But when you combine it as part of a word can also be pronounced ふた、ふ、ふう or じ

Which is somewhat analogous to how 'p' and 'h' have one pronunciation (that I can think of off the top of my head), but when they're combined, you get an 'f' sound.

Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by harisenbon on Friday July 23, 2010 @02:38AM (#1540523)
It's comments like this that makes me wish that Hackernews had a "follow" button. =)

The problem with the pitch accent is that it varies so much by region that if you included them in the kana (like the universal phonetic alphabet) you would end up with something that was completely unreadable by people from a different prefecture. (Ok, I'm taking that to an extreme, but still. The Japanese have enough problems with various dialects without putting pitches in the written language. I think I would cry.)

Another interesting thing is that even within the kana there are slight variations in pronunciation. in 三年、三万、三月 all the んs are pronounced differently.

I think we should agree that all language is fubared. Except for Esperonto. And no one uses that (no matter what the wikipedia page says).

Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by w1ntermute on Friday July 23, 2010 @01:26PM (#1541790)
The problem with the pitch accent is that it varies so much by region that if you included them in the kana (like the universal phonetic alphabet) you would end up with something that was completely unreadable by people from a different prefecture. (Ok, I'm taking that to an extreme, but still. The Japanese have enough problems with various dialects without putting pitches in the written language. I think I would cry.)

Yeah, that's definitely true. You would have to use it just for 標準語, sort of like how pinyin with tonal diacritics is primarily used for Standard Mandarin, since something like 関西弁 would look completely different.

By the way, I remember reading (on HN, I believe) that a lot of the problems with English spelling are a result of the original typesetters (i.e., for Gutenberg-style printing presses) being Dutch, so they failed to accurately spell a lot of English words.

And Esperanto is for noobs ;) If you want to see a real conlang built from the ground up, check out Ilaksh: http://www.ithkuil.net/ilaksh/Ilaksh_Intro.html

Re:Character Amnesia: Negative Impact of Computers Upon Writ... by Jd on Friday July 23, 2010 @11:33PM (#1543038)
Fubar can be a design principle. Perfect transparency is not desirable in every and all circumstances and often hoops are constructed just so that people will jump through them.