News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by tfinniga on Thursday April 03, 2008 @12:42PM (#153968)
Well if you ignore the human visual processing system, that's a valid argument. One ascii character is just the same as the next.

Unfortunately for lisp, that's not the case. Whitespace is different than lines. There's a reason most people can't look past the parens - they're hard to look past.

Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by e40 on Thursday April 03, 2008 @03:22PM (#154150)
I think this is a feeble excuse. That is, it's an excuse generated by a lazy mind. The first time I saw Lisp, I was not "primed" to dislike it. It was early in my programming education. I was fresh, as they say. It looked no more cluttered than Pascal, the main language being taught at the time.

Can I write really ugly and hard to visually parse Lisp? Yes. Bad code can be written in any language.

Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by dpapathanasiou on Thursday April 03, 2008 @03:29PM (#154161)
Parenthesis fade into the background with experience (especially if your code is well-formatted), in the same way you start to group things by curly braces in C or Java over time.

No one looks at C code the first time and thinks it's clear to understand.

Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by tfinniga on Thursday April 03, 2008 @04:18PM (#154213)
The point I was trying to make is that whitespace and parens are not equally good as delimiters.

Specifically, reading a newspaper that has parens instead of whitespace would be harder.

(Specifically,(reading(a(newspaper(that(has(parens(instead(of(whitespace (would(be(harder.)))))))))))))

In terms of actually being a problem, I'd say it depends on the code, for sure. I could create that same example in C, but end it with }}}}}}}}}}}}}}. However, in my admittedly limited experience with lisp, it seems more likely to be highly nested, tempting people to put more levels on a single line.

I also agree with you that C shouldn't be held up as the paragon of readability.

Python is pretty darn good though.

Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by edu on Thursday April 03, 2008 @04:32PM (#154230)
But you can format and indent your lisp code so the reader (people) doesn't have to rely on counting parentheses.

Example from taken from http://www.gigamonkeys.com/book/

  (defun test-+ ()
    (let ((*test-name* 'test-+)
          (another-var 'foo))
      (check 
        (= (+ 1 2) 3) 
        (= (+ 1 2 3) 5) 
        (= (+ -1 -3) -4))))

You should be able to read what this code does (check basically runs the statements and reports if they return true or false) without having to count a single parentheses.
Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by tfinniga on Thursday April 03, 2008 @04:52PM (#154254)
I agree that lisp can be made readable. And C can be made unreadable.

OTOH lisp encourages deep nesting, which makes it harder to be readable. Here's a rougly equivalent program, if I read the lisp correctly.

  void test-+()
  {
     *test-name* = test-+;
     another-var = foo;
     assert( 1+2 == 3 );
     assert( 1+2+3 == 5 );
     assert( -1 + -3 == -4 );
  }
I'm not saying that this is any better than the lisp equivalent - the lisp function is certainly more elegant. But because C is procedural/stateful, it's more natural to have flatter programs.

And flat programs are easier to make legible, because you're less tempted to put multiple things on a single line to avoid going another level deeper in your indenation.

Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by edu on Thursday April 03, 2008 @05:31PM (#154305)
I agree that the C version is slightly more readable than the Lisp version, but this slight improvement comes to a big price which is the difficulty to programmatically parse and generate C code.
Re:Why Lisp Is Unpopular by hernan7 on Thursday April 03, 2008 @03:09PM (#154131)
I think parens would be less of a problem if the indentation conventions were easier on the eyes. Sometimes you need a ruler to figure out those 1-space indentations.