News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Die young, live fast: The evolution of an underclass by nostrademons on Thursday July 22, 2010 @04:35PM (#1539472)
"The very idea that such behavior is driven by genetic impulses is something that shows a flawed understanding of the entire concept at some stage by the writer."

The article isn't saying that poverty is caused by genes, it's saying that the the behavior of having more children earlier when poor is caused by genes. Which is exactly the same sort of "coder" analogy that Richard Dawkins points out. It then says that this behavior then tends to "trap" individuals into this particular behavior, as any deviation from it results in fewer offspring surviving. In the game theory world, this is an evolutionarily stable strategy.

There are lots of instances where genes encode behaviors that are conditionally expressed by the environment, eg. the phenomenon where most mammals tend to have more girl babies then boys when times are bad, and vice versa when times are good.

Re:Die young, live fast: The evolution of an underclass by todayiamme on Thursday July 22, 2010 @04:49PM (#1539508)
I am so sorry that I couldn't get my point across effectively. What I was trying to say was that the idea that such behavior tends to trap people into poverty is a derivative of our genetic code is extremely deterministic.

Of course, you're right, but you forget that these are people capable of making a conscious choice. They are people who if given the right resources and understanding can choose otherwise. Perhaps we have a higher tendency of making such choices due to our genetic makeup, but that's what it exactly is a tendency. It is not an absolute, and my problem isn't the fact that this happens.

It is the fact that this does happen and that despite the fact those people can choose whenever someone meets them they will label them under something like this. We talk about them as mammals and subjects. This is a good thing when you're trying to get down to the facts, but we need to remember this; they are people, human beings with feelings, desires, dreams, aspirations, hopes and pain. If we want to help them we should respect them not label them.

[Edit: Made a few changes to make it more clear]

Re:Die young, live fast: The evolution of an underclass by jseliger on Thursday July 22, 2010 @07:11PM (#1539846)
What I was trying to say was that the idea that such behavior tends to trap people into poverty is a derivative of our genetic code is extremely deterministic.

I think the key word here is "tends:" as far as I know, no evolutionary biologists or psychologists would argue a 1:1 correspondence between these kinds of situations and behavior. But, from both a game theory and evolutionary point of view, the kind of behavior described in the article makes sense. This isn't at all about being "extremely deterministic;" it's about analyzing how people might respond to certain forces and situations. They will have free will and can still exert their preferences in a wide variety of ways.

I think the author of the study and many others are trying to figure out how genes and environment interact -- which turns out to be a far more complex question than many simplifiers would have (and I'm not saying you're one of them).

For more on the topic of genes/environments in a less contentious / politically loaded setting, see "The Orchid Child" in The Atlantic: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/12/the-scie... .