Re:HP Enterprise let Russia scrutinize cyberdefense system u...
by inetknght on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @08:51AM
(#15392025)
...now enter fuzz testing and your first statement goes out the window.
Re:HP Enterprise let Russia scrutinize cyberdefense system u...
by evgen on Tuesday October 03, 2017 @09:06AM
(#15392095)
Fuzz testing is far, far easier and more complete if you have the source code. It is not required to have the source to fuzz, but white-box fuzzing can be combined with code coverage analysis to make sure you hit all code paths, including ones that would rely upon a more structured sequencing of the inputs. Black-box fuzzing could eventually reach the same end result, but it would take far longer or far more resources.
The "security-by-obscurity" point does apply when you compare "going open-source with many observers" to "being closed-source with no one looking", but this is not the case here.