This is good. My version of "slow code" is taking note of requests from users and storing in my long term memory to stew over.
1. User A says "It would be nice to have feature X"
2. I ask for more info, what problem are they trying to solve
3. Repeat steps 1 and 2 until user's stop saying "nice to have" and start saying "must have". The stew is now ready and development can begin now that I have thought about a solution that can address everyone's problems...just in time before users get angry :)
A good talk about It, from the creator of clojure:
I guess the phrase 'rush to judgement' is instructive. We're not just thinking, we're deciding of course.
If you can find out about a problem or issue or desire and very quickly come up with an architectural solution that will stand the test of time for years (at least without backwards-incompatibilities, which is what a redis requires), more power to you, but in my experience and observation most will not.
But I get it, you just don't agree with my basic suggestion, from your experience. That's fine. It's not really an argument about the speed of one's thinking. Nobody is "confused".
No not really. It's called waterfall and we had it for decades.
And it was largely abandoned in favour of agile development because despite architects spending months designing something there was always something that was left out. Or the scope changed during those months. Or millions of other things that change whilst your hidden away from your customers/end users instead of delivering them new value every week.
For me personally the truth is somewhere between agile and waterfall. Some upfront design but not the slow code you refer to.
I also agree with the person who responded that there is a difference between building products, and building tools for building products -- building shared libraries/code/tools may require different approaches. One of the things I've noticed about shared code, is it's _much harder_ to fix rethought decisions or change paths. "Backwards incompatibility" doesn't even exist as a thing in your local app really, at least you can always at least theoretically global search and replace when you change APIs.
I don't think we've figured out any magic bullet process for developing software. It's definitely not the stereotype of "waterfall", but I don't think the stereotype of "agile" is it either -- at _least_ when it comes to shared library/tools. And I'm absolutely convinced that those shared tools which do well were almost always designed carefully and intentionally with understanding of the domain, not just slapped together with stimulus-response.
I've been thinking about this sort of thing for a while, wanting to maybe call it "slow code" (like "slow food"). This is how actual quality software that will stand the test of time gets designed and made, _slowly_, _carefully_, _intentionally_, with thought and discussion and feedback and reconsideration. And always based on understanding the domain and the existing software you are building upon. Not jumping from problem to a PR to a merge. (And _usually_ by one person, sometimes a couple/several working together, _rarely_ by committee).