News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by sudosteph on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:14PM (#15385748)
The really ironic part of this is that while VCs will claim "America First" is exclusionary(it is), their practice of "Silicon Valley First" is accepted as a normal fact of life.

Opportunity in America is not equal. Many smart, working class kids would love to be an entrepreneur, and it's not lack of ambition or talent holding them back. It's simple economics and lack of mentorship or investment available.

I'm all for bringing more entrepeneurs into the US. But I wish VCs were half as interested in growing talent here, at public universities across the nation and in cities not as hip as SFO.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by markh on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:23PM (#15385837)
The kind of entrepreneurs most likely to succeed (and therefore gain the attention of VCs) figure out how to relocate to startup hubs where they can get the attention of the VC community and network their way into the ecosystem. It’s way easier to move from Florida to San Francisco that it is from Paris, Sydney or Cape Town, and the extra hoops foreign entrepreneurs have to jump through makes them stand out all the more (relatively speaking). Very few American entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley grew up there either. It becomes a self-selecting sample.
Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by sudosteph on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:36PM (#15385959)
And for those people who have legitimate reasons to not relocate to the most expensive area in the U.S.? You know, reasons like familial obligations and limited safety net income? They should just accept that they weren't likely to succeed in the first place, because otherwise they would have relocated?

That's nonsense. Plenty of very successful companies run succesfully somewhere other than SV. If you run a tech shop, that knows what you're doing, has the talent and resources on-hand, you don't need to be in SV other than for networking (which you only need to do to get those talent and resources in the first place).

I would love to see numbers on long-term success vs funding numbers by city. I'd argue that for long-term success and a customer base that is consumer oriented (as opposed to B2B which does benefit from SFO or NYC), a location with lower expenses and less employee turnover due to less competition seems beneficial. Worked for starting Amazon and Microsoft, some of the THE most successful companies right now (even if Seattle is becoming more like SF every day now).

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by markh on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:44PM (#15386034)
The article above is specifically about VC-funded companies by definition. Nobody is arguing that you can’t be a successful entrepreneur outside of a startup hub. But if you’re going to play the “bubble metrics” game, raise VC, grow rapidly and exit for “bubble metrics” valuations, your odds are way higher if you move. Silicon Valley is generally full of young founders. They move before they have families. They couch-surf, eat ramen noodles and don’t let concern for a safety net impede possible success (however unlikely that is).
Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by sudosteph on Monday October 02, 2017 @02:00PM (#15386197)
Parents are family. Siblings are family. If you have the ability move across the country without worrying if your family will be able to get by without you helping them either in person or financially, you already have a safety net that many working class Americans don't.

Everyone ate ramen in college to get by, but most folks had the option to go back home and stay with their parents if college didn't work out. That's what you're describing here. Please don't conflate choosing to live frugally in exchange for additional opportunity with Americans who actually have grown up watching parents work two jobs only to choose between going to the doctor or paying their car payment (which they need to earn income). That's what working class means, that's what not having a safety net means. The consequences are different.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by QAPereo on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:39PM (#15385984)
As far as I can tell, most big VCs are essentially children who care about little more than power, recognition, and maybe being the first trillionaire. If you filter out the incessant talk and focus only on actions, it becomes clear.
Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by paxy on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:43PM (#15386028)
VCs aren't in the business of developing talent, they want to set up and mentor startups and make money. They believe (correctly or not) that the best place to do this is in Silicon Valley, so they want entrepreneurs from the US and beyond to relocate there. What is "ironic" about this?
Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by anindha on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:33PM (#15385920)
Could you explain what you mean by the "economics" holding them back? Someone living here starts off in a much better position than any foreign entrepreneur. If they can't figure out how to get the attention of an investor then they probably wouldn't be a great entrepreneur.
Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by htormey on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:48PM (#15386076)
" Someone living here starts off in a much better position than any foreign entrepreneur. "

I don't think you can make a blanket statement like that. I come from Ireland where I received a 4 year degree in CS for free. Most of the Americans I worked with over the years are saddled with huge amounts of college debt. This is a massive advantage in my favor.

Having to spend 4-6 years waiting for a green card so I can start my own company is a massive disadvantage. Having to deal with the annoying vagaries of the US immigration system just to get a job is also a massive disadvantage.

Coming from a country that has good free high school education is a massive advantage compared to most places in the USA.

Having parents who are financially well off and can support you while you are in school is a massive advantage. Having parents who went to university and can tell you the difference between schools or guide you through the byzantine application processes are massive advantages.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by anindha on Monday October 02, 2017 @02:32PM (#15386483)
Many students here receive financial aid - 69% of Stanford undergraduates [1].

[1] http://news.stanford.edu/2016/02/25/tuition-financial-aid-02...

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by htormey on Monday October 02, 2017 @03:16PM (#15386989)
Sure, Stanford, Harvard & many top tier universities provide financial aid. I think that's awesome and to be encouraged. Getting into those institutions or being even aware of them is another matter. The disadvantages that many American's face start way downstream in high school, etc.

If you don't have parents who have gone to college before or go to a school with good teachers, you probably won't even know to apply to a top tier school.

A common theme that I have seen amongst my friends who have gone to Stanford/Berkeley/etc is that their parents had them doing extracurricular activities from a very young age to pad their entrance letters. Poorer families, have less resources and hence less time to engage in activities like this.

Just getting into Stanford or a top US college requires an incredible amount of work above and beyond good grades.

I have a very good friend who charge's $200 an hour to put together college application letters for top schools.

Income inequality in the USA is a huge disadvantage that many Americans face.

I'm not saying that income inequality is not an issue many immigrants don't face. I'm just particularly aware of it coming from a country (Ireland) that has good social benefits, like free healthcare, educations, etc. I think these things put me at an advantage compared to what many of my American peers had to go through.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by literallycancer on Monday October 02, 2017 @02:43PM (#15386633)
1. Be American in SF.

2. Rent out your apartment.

3. Go to Europe, live from the rent money.

4. Get a degree.

5. Profit?

If you don't own a property:

0. Save for a year, then do the same thing.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by lghh on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:36PM (#15385956)
> Someone living here starts off in a much better position than any foreign entrepreneur.

This is an incredibly untrue statement.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by TheAdamAndChe on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:51PM (#15386093)
To expand upon this statement, social mobility has been on the decline[1] at a time when income inequality in the US is reaching unparalleled levels[2]. Childhood poverty is on the rise[3], and regional inequality is incredible[4]. All this is occurring at a time when the best and brightest young people are ending up with tens of thousands of dollars of debt just to be able to enter the workforce.

All this is why small business creation is on the decline here.[5] It takes money to make money, and the lower and middle classes just don't have money to spare.

edit: To those downvoting me, can you please explain? I don't understand the flaw(s) in my statement.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socioeconomic_mobility_in_the_...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_inequality_in_the_Unite...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#C...

[4] https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2012/08/07/regiona...

[5] http://money.cnn.com/2016/09/08/news/economy/us-startups-nea...

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by notyourday on Monday October 02, 2017 @01:55PM (#15386142)
This is absolutely correct.

If the 'foreign entrepreneur' is rich then he or she does not need VC help to immigrate into the United States. I know a few - it just requires being able to get in via O visa, which is easy for a rich person[1]. So this means that the foreign entrepreneur in question is not rich.

A non-rich foreign entrepreneur is unlikely to have the kind of salary that allows one to throw money at the problem to make inconveniences of switching countries go away:

1. Establishing personal credit, bank accounts, dealing with financial institutions, insurance etc

2. Getting state issued drivers license and dealing with Government

3. Getting an apartment

4. Developing a quick understanding of good v. bad areas, social norms (poor person with terrible habits is an asshole. Rich person with the same habits is eccentric ), etc

[1] Edit: In a response to the comment below - lets define "rich" as someone with a few million in assets with a million of that being liquid.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by htormey on Monday October 02, 2017 @02:15PM (#15386345)
For those not in the know, here is the definition of an O Visa is:

"An O visa is a classification of non-immigrant temporary worker visa granted by the United States to an alien "who possesses extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics, or who has a demonstrated record of extraordinary achievement in the motion picture or television industry and has been recognized nationally or internationally for those achievements," "

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O_visa

I don't think this is quite as easy to obtain as the parent implies as you need to have a reputation & have money to pull it off. Not just any rich person will be able to do this without spending a bunch of time cultivating the former.

The people I know who have gotten this visa had quite a long history of published (news papers, journals, etc) achievements.

It was also very stressful for them as at any stage in the process the government could decide that their achievements were not significant enough and pull the plug on their application.

Re:VCs are suing the US for delay of immigration program by taysic on Monday October 02, 2017 @03:55PM (#15387353)
I'm not sure about the details of this exact program but if someone who wants to come live in America, that means there is an added "value" to this program that the VC's don't have to pay for. I'm using the H1B program in mind here. Those people will possibly be more negotiable and possibly willing to take deals that others wouldn't for the same or less amount of money - simply because there is an added factor to the arrangement.