News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by toddh on Thursday July 22, 2010 @11:51AM (#1538483)
What could possibly go wrong? We've done so well engineering complex ecosystems that there's certainly no possibility of unintended consequences. For a great example of success take a look at rabbits in Australia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabbits_in_Australia) and perch in Lake Victoria (http://www.cichlid-forum.com/articles/lake_victoria_sick.php).
Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by jerf on Thursday July 22, 2010 @12:19PM (#1538602)
Look at Therac-25, the Ariane 5, and the Mars Surveyor! Therefore we should stop all programming!

Argument-by-disaster is a terrible argument, there is not a single human endeavor that has not led to disaster at some point. It proves too much.

Reflexively decrying all environmental modification is at best a cognitive shortcut which should be discarded when it doesn't apply, at worst institutionalized stupidity-by-choice. Dismissing some crank on the Internet who offhandedly mumbles something about eliminating mosquitoes with "what could go wrong?" is appropriate. Dismissing a serious article that seriously asks the question and considers the consequences is a disservice to everyone involved in the article.

You're getting upvoted because you are giving people a chance to mentally feel good about their environmental bona fides because they upvoted you, not because you're making an even remotely valuable argument or contribution.

Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by mitjak on Thursday July 22, 2010 @12:32PM (#1538641)
Agreed, but the main point still stands: there can definitely be factors outside of our knowledge and control which we will simply not be aware of until it is too late. The old "life would be so much easier without this little nature's imperfection" attitude has brought some unintended and tragic consequences more than once.
Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by mtomczak on Thursday July 22, 2010 @12:46PM (#1538688)
Thanks to the general availability and utilization of vaccines against smallpox and polio, massive improvements in sanitation and emergency response, and long-term cardiac therapy, the death rate due to cancers is radically up.

Cancer is a horrible disesase. Which one of those changes should we not have made to end up in the situation we're in today?

Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by mitjak on Thursday July 22, 2010 @01:18PM (#1538827)
What causes cancer outside of factors brought about by human intervention?
Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by jerf on Thursday July 22, 2010 @01:31PM (#1538877)
No, it doesn't stand. It proves too much. It proves you should never take any action, and for that matter also that "no action" isn't acceptable either. This is not a useful thing to "prove".

See also the logically-unsound "precautionary principle", which has the exact same problem for the exact same reason.

Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by Tichy on Thursday July 22, 2010 @01:40PM (#1538908)
He only said "what could possibly go wrong", hardly the same as saying "it should never, ever be attempted".

It would be interesting to hear some success stories in contrast? I suppose stuff like importing potatoes would count?

Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by anamax on Thursday July 22, 2010 @01:17PM (#1538826)
> Agreed, but the main point still stands: there can definitely be factors outside of our knowledge and control which we will simply not be aware of until it is too late.

There are always such factors.

Take the choice whether to have a child. Said child may be the next Hitler, so clearly it's wrong to have a child. But wait, said child may be the person who stops the next Hitler, so there's almost an obligation to have said child.

Pointing out that there are unknowns is useless. More to the point, it isn't an argument for or against anything because it applies just as well to all options.

Re:Nature thinks we could safely wipe mosquitoes off the fac... by MartinCron on Thursday July 22, 2010 @01:06PM (#1538766)
Argument-by-disaster is terrible when it's shallow and leads people to jump to conclusions too soon. Spectacular success and spectacular failure can both be illustrative in their own way.

The only problem I have with Therac-25 is that it's overused, surely we have other catastrophic programming examples?