Destroying the world's most biodiverse ecosystem (seriously, read some statistics on number of species in the Amazon -- it's mind boggling) to grow the GDP by 10% is not just incredibly selfish (supposedly exchanging a global treasure for national gain). It's not even the best for our own interests; it's myopic, greedy, inhumane. Even the actual direct economic value of scientific research with industrial applications such as biomimicry research, plants with applications in medicine and food industry, etc. would completely dwarf a one time 10% gain. And then there's the hardly measurable value of lost knowledge and natural richness.
Don't be the child exclaiming "But my brother was greedy too!". This is our treasure, and our responsibility.
If greed ends up winning and most of the forest is destroyed, Brazil will find itself without a national treasure, and likely be economically worse off for it.
Some of the worlds major economic success stories are countries with few natural resources, Taiwan being a common example. At the same time, there are a number of countries heavily exploiting their resources, yet seemingly without alleviating their poverty.
There are plenty of places trying to re-forest, which also suggests that you might get stuck with the long term cost of trying to undo the damage done.
In Michigan we have a few little pockets of real old growth forest and national forests the size of a small country.
But policies and agendas, imposed from countries abroad, changes the mindset of everybody very fast.
Funny thing. 8%. completely comparable to the amount of land in Brazil is owned by the government, or is regulated and so on.
It's no wonder that regulation and enforcement has improved things lately(in Brazil!), but why the fuck do we need to follow agendas from abroad, just like I've said before, getting shitty trade deals? :-)
More simply modern economy gains little from farm land as there exists such an over supply of food that farming tends to be break even or be a net economic loss.
That said, people will always be interested in extracting value from pubic lands at the public expense.