Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy
by nodamage on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:47PM
(#15361026)
> I've used my personal income which was already taxed at the state and federal level, put it into the market at my own risk, and then gets taxed again when I get gains on it.
Except the money you originally put in is not taxed again. Only the gains are. I don't see a compelling argument as to why your gains should also be tax free.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy
by influx on Thursday September 28, 2017 @06:13PM
(#15361204)
I never said they should be tax free, only that as a small time investor they should be modestly taxed.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy
by r00fus on Thursday September 28, 2017 @08:18PM
(#15361846)
That's what progressive taxation is all about - low tax rates for low income, high rates for high income.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy
by nemo44x on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:36PM
(#15360944)
Indeed and why I said that the "standard deduction" should be higher than labor. This means people who do not use the markets as a primary source of income but rather as a tool to go from no wealth to acquiring wealth aren't paying taxes on it for reasons you've stated. Or a minimal tax.
But once you've become a successful investor over the years and have acquired more and more wealth your dividends are starting to get taxed higher and your proceeds which are now comparable to an income or possibly a primary income are becoming taxed. Because of compound interest and appreciation of capital assets you're being taxed on your new wealth.
I've used my personal income which was already taxed at the state and federal level, put it into the market at my own risk, and then gets taxed again when I get gains on it. Now, because Bill Gates and Warren Buffet aren't getting taxed enough, you're hurting the small time folks.
You're creating a moat whereby the small time folks can never escape, and the folks who have already made it won't be hurt.