News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by WalterBright on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:24PM (#15360861)
> This creates more consumption and investment which leads to better markets.

This is another variation on the old "rich people hoard cash" trope.

Rich people invest the money that they don't spend. They tend to invest well, meaning highly productive investments, because (naturally) wealthy people get wealthy by being good at investing.

Productive investments are good for the economy. The notion that wealthy people invest in unproductive things doesn't make any sense.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by viraptor on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:45PM (#15361002)
> because (naturally) wealthy people get wealthy by being good at investing.

[Citation needed]. There's lots of wealthy people who got funded, got lucky (some investments are good only looking back - would you like to pay me to sign a few bytes 7 years ago?), got family fund, play the right sport in the right country, etc. People can get continuously more wealthy just by owning things - at that point you can outsource the investing to someone good at it. We've got very well known examples of people who inherited fortunes, failed at investing it multiple times and are still wealthy.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by WalterBright on Friday September 29, 2017 @12:29AM (#15362720)
> [Citation needed]

See "The Millionaire Next Door" by Stanley

It stands to reason that if wealthy people as a group are bad at investing, they'd sooner or later stop being wealthy. Then, by survivorship bias, the wealthy ones remaining were good at investing.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by nemo44x on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:29PM (#15360895)
Which is why you lower the corporate tax rate. This gives companies more leverage to use the investment money they get. They can purchase assets, fund R&D, buy smaller promising companies, and hire more labor.

Right now they will use any savings to buy back stock - that's the rational thing to do and makes the investors happy. But if we tax investment income progressively then buying back stock is great for the US Treasury - someone has to sell that stock to the company buying it back and it's taxed more!

It becomes more reasonable to reinvest that money from a corporate perspective. This is what the investors will want done.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by WalterBright on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:32PM (#15360909)
> Right now they will use any savings to buy back stock

It seems you imagine that isn't actual investment. Of course it is, just like anyone else buying stock is investing the money.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by mdemare on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:38PM (#15360956)
No, actually this is not investment. It’s returning money to shareholders who may decide to invest, or they may not.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by WalterBright on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:53PM (#15361078)
The money gets spent or invested. Not hoarded. Invested money gets spent as well. After all, companies do not sell shares unless they intend to spend the proceeds. It's the whole point.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by pharrington on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:54PM (#15361085)
That has little to do with money hoarding.

One aspect of wealth is that it's a capture of some local increase in human-useful efficiency. The most common use of large amounts of wealth is to buy more capital. All systems have a limit to their efficiency, and even when efficiency improvements are possible, it's often not obvious or easy to achieve them. What is easier, though, is to decrease efficiency in a neighborhood you do not own, and then use capital to provide a more efficient solution to that neighborhood's problem in a neighborhood you do own. Clearly this is bad for the greater economy, yet is a good investment for the foreseeable future for those who can afford it.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by chromatic on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:59PM (#15361107)
Productive investments are good for the economy.

Are they? Or are you defining "productive" circularly here?

If I'm wealthy and I invest in derivatives or complicated tranches, is that "productive" because it's enabling further circulation of money, or is it "productive" because I can gain more capital on it?

Given that there's an infinite supply of ever more derived tranches, I suspect that my definition of "productive" different from yours here.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by WalterBright on Friday September 29, 2017 @12:35AM (#15362736)
Digging down into what investment is, your are providing money to a person with the expectation that he will give you more back. Somehow, that extra has to be produced.

Analogously to a flying airplane - it is producing more lift than its weight. This must be true even if you haven't the slightest idea how all the whorls of air and eddies around it are created or how they influence the airplane.

What derivatives do is they spread risk in exchange for a lower rate of return, as well as provide liquidity. This is a productive thing that financial markets provide.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by lr4444lr on Thursday September 28, 2017 @05:41PM (#15360971)
Sure, but there's a flow rate problem: they're predominantly good at a productive skill whose fruits are taxed at a lower rate than those of people with different productive skills. Now, because most people have some stake in investment, the progressive rates could start quite high - maybe in the tens of millions - but the monetary system simply won't work forever at the trajectory its on.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by WalterBright on Thursday September 28, 2017 @06:01PM (#15361130)
> the monetary system simply won't work forever at the trajectory its on.

It can under a fiat money system (which we've had since 1914). If you or I borrow money, we have to pay it back. That's not so for the government with fiat money. It can just print more money anytime, or do the equivalent (issue more bonds), and it can do this forever.

This is why the dollar today is worth just a few cents of what it was worth in 1914. (The 1914 dollar was worth the same as the 1800 dollar.)

Check out "Monetary History of the United States" by Friedman.

Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by lr4444lr on Thursday September 28, 2017 @07:16PM (#15361569)
That's the Chartalist (and MMT view, I think). Friedman did make a strong case for the central bank's role like you describe to end recessions, but he was also sensitive to the fact that money was not identical to productive capacity, ie that which would produce capital gains. The concern as I understand it is that unless you did something radical like literally gave the cash to people directly, there is still the liquidity trap with the central bank's levers.
Re:Tax Plan Punts on a Loophole for the Wealthy by WalterBright on Friday September 29, 2017 @12:37AM (#15362738)
Friedman showed in MH that the stability of the money supply was greater with the "blind" operations of the market than with the enlightened levers of the Fed.