Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow
by barrkel on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @11:23AM
(#1535430)
I think it looks hideous - it reminds me intensely of phpBB, with the author icon / info etc. on the left, and the stench of phpBB is definitely to be avoided (IMHO).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow
by MartinCron on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:14PM
(#1535582)
"stench of phpBB" is the most compelling thing I've read in some time.
Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow
by slantyyz on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:45PM
(#1535699)
Ouch!
In the Stack Overflow podcasts, that is the one app they strived to be so vastly different from.
Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow
by mkinsella on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:17PM
(#1535589)
Keep in mind the author-icon/info-on-left concept isn't exclusive to phpBB, it's used by most forum software. It's used so frequently because it's what the user expects which is what drove this layout: making the site easier to use for first time users coming from Google.
Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow
by LargeWu on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:06PM
(#1535765)
The difference is that SO is not a forum, it's a question and answer site. A key distinction. I think SO's current design serves its purpose well.
Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow
by rmc on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @06:10PM
(#1536718)
One of the reasons SO was created is cause forums are usually so bad at serving as Q&A sites.
Re:A Case Study of “Designed By Developers:” Stack Overflow
by sprout on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:47PM
(#1535707)
Personally, I'd much rather be compared to phpBB than SO. PhpBB has a proven track record as one of the most powerful and widely-used forum tools on the web. SO is still young, and could very well peter out. I've always found its ad placement extremely grating.