News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by qjz on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @10:49AM (#1535304)
I don't know, I think it's fair to say that computing is a field where really smart, but shy, individuals can participate and excel, compared to many other fields of work. That doesn't mean that everyone in computing fits that description, but it does suggest this group will be overrepresented.

He goes on to say, "Every developer I’ve ever worked with, for instance, is probably more qualified to be a member of Congress than most of the members of Congress we have now." I could say the same about almost everyone I've ever known. The problem is that politics isn't appealing to the type of individuals we consider exemplary, regardless of background. Just look at local politics, where you'll often find aimless drifters or self-serving candidates on the ballot among others who understand that government is complicated machine that needs to be run competently for everyone's benefit. But back on topic, how many of your school board or city council members are also software developers? My guess is few or none, because they just aren't interested or feel that it's too challenging to promote logical solutions in an environment of irrational rivalry.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by api on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @10:58AM (#1535342)
Hmm... let's see...

Politics is a field that is underpaid and consists of mainly putting out fires, being beat on the head by numerous (often very slimy) special interests, trying to convince fickle people to vote for you, and being blamed for everything that's wrong and ignored when things go right.

Count me in!

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by axod on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @11:03AM (#1535363)
The pay is a large issue. In the UK, being a Member of Parliament, you get around £65k. That doesn't compare well to business jobs of similar responsibility etc.

Even the prime minister is on less pay than several civil servants which is ridiculous. No wonder we have so many people in government from wealthy families.

I don't remember quite where it was but I read that somewhere in Asia the government/MPs get paid a million or so, which results in better people, and obviously less corruption/fiddling accounts etc.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by russell on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @04:57PM (#1536528)
Even more than salary in the US is the cost of getting elected. The CA governors race is going into the 9 digits. It cost millions to elect a congressman, 10's of millions for a senator. The only one with that kind of money are unions, corporations, and rich candidates. The candidates are bought and have to deliver. This is corruption on a massive and pervasive scale. And it's legal.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by api on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @11:06AM (#1535375)
Wow... that's worse than I thought.

I've often wondered if part of the problem with mismanagement and corruption in government is that politicians are actually underpaid. Anyone really good wants to go into business or marketing, fields that demand similar skills but that pay way better. Corruption becomes a problem because it's the only way to get a raise...

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by evilduck on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:56PM (#1535922)
Not necessarily just politicians, but government workers in general. Low level people like janitors are generally overcompensated compared to their peers, but higher positions like programmers, scientists, analysts, managers, etc, typically make far less than their industry counterparts. I personally know a few government scientists who make about 40% of their industry peers.

Because of that, I think you see a lot of corruption, indifference, or laziness due to workers "compensating" for the pay differences. It certainly doesn't help morale.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by jacoblyles on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @03:16PM (#1536211)
Singapore tries to keep their public sector compensation on par with corporate executives. It's a good idea IMO.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by SandB0x on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @02:12PM (#1535990)
Another reason is that to get into politics, graduates normally have to do unpaid internships to get a foot in the door. This is only really an option if your family is well off.

The prime minister gets to live in 10 Downing Street, and can look forward to lucrative book deals, after dinner speeches and consulting gigs (Blair was getting £500k to advise JP Morgan). This isn't true for most jobs. It's not such a bad deal, but obviously most people don't get that far.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by baha_man on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @11:53AM (#1535520)
> In the UK, being a Member of Parliament, you get around £65k.

Yes, but until recently their salaries were being supplemented by very generous expenses. They were also allowed to take on other work, subject to certain rules.

> Even the prime minister is on less pay than several civil servants which is ridiculous.

Former prime ministers can earn a fortune, however, just look at Tony Blair. Retired MPs can also cash in, to a lesser extent, on their time in office.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by axod on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:02PM (#1535558)
>> "Former prime ministers can earn a fortune, however, just look at Tony Blair. Retired MPs can also cash in, to a lesser extent, on their time in office. "

Right. Which IMHO is a bad idea. PM's are paid a bad salary, but know that they can go work for big.co after they're done being PM. That leaves them wide open to corruption.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by hugh3 on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @06:52PM (#1536810)
A good argument for giving them a Barony and kicking them into the House of Lords, perhaps?
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by kierank on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:56PM (#1535921)
You could argue that considering the public perception of MPs right now £65k isn't too bad for them.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by hboon on Thursday July 22, 2010 @02:51AM (#1537531)
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by raystar on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @11:55AM (#1535530)
By what measure is 65k a small amount of money, from what i remember the average wage in the uk is ~26k, and many full time workers earn much less than this.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by axod on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:05PM (#1535563)
I didn't say it was small. It's certainly small for what an MP/PM entails. Even a middle manager in some average company would expect to be on £65k.

So there is a massive disconnect between what members of parliament get paid, and what they would get if they moved into the private sector business world. The issue is that voters as you say, are on average paid a lot less, so they don't understand this point.

Personally, I'd like to see the PM paid £1m or so. MPs maybe £250k. I would expect them to be less corruptable and more focussed.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by raystar on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @05:08PM (#1536561)
I'm unaware that the wage for a PM is the main motivating interest for most, in this case David Cameron being I assume at least moderately wealthy, the comparison is flawed I feel.

I don't agree that paying MPs more would create an environment for less corruption, I have so far seen little restraint in human greed, and even those at the very top of the pay scale are not above eking more out of the system.

What would help with corruption, would be a more open lobbying system, restrictions on the jobs MPs can take after leaving parliament and ensuring members of the cabinet cannot be employed when they have obvious biases, a former oil company head being minister for energy for example.

Also as is obviously the case in many industries, Health and Social Care being one, the private sector model does not always make sense.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by axod on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @05:41PM (#1536635)
I disagree. It's the same with teaching. Why become a teacher of X and get paid Y, when you can just become a professional X and get paid 2Y?

I'm in no way saying the private model always makes sense. What I'm saying is that the reason we perhaps have poor choice of MPs, is because all the people who would make great MPs are earning a decent wage in the private business world.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by tomjen3 on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:31PM (#1535647)
Because the average person isn't going to be fit to be a PM. The amount of responsibility that a PM entails is more than what would be required as CEO of most smaller companies, yet they would make a lot more.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by cjoh on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @11:08AM (#1535389)
170k in US.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by Retric on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @03:48PM (#1536314)
£65k = ~98.8k in the US. But, even still 170k is penuts to the type of people that can get those jobs.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by cjoh on Saturday July 24, 2010 @09:25AM (#1543592)
Sorry, i meant 170k is how much members of congress get paid
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by Aaronontheweb on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:44PM (#1535696)
"I don't know, I think it's fair to say that computing is a field where really smart, but shy, individuals can participate and excel, compared to many other fields of work. "

I'd argue that the IQ distribution amongst programmers is no different than that of the general population - there are just more people who mistakenly believe that they're smarter because they can throw together spaghetti code in a text editor.

As for this stereotype about social intelligence being an issue with most programmers - I call b.s. on that too. There are plenty of programmers who know how to socialize and how to relate to people - they're just not the ones portrayed in mass media.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by zephyrfalcon on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @12:55PM (#1535732)
"I'd argue that the IQ distribution amongst programmers is no different than that of the general population - there are just more people who mistakenly believe that they're smarter because they can throw together spaghetti code in a text editor."

That would imply that the average IQ of programmers is 100. Seems unlikely, I do think it attracts people smarter than average (at least in times when programming is not "popular" because big $$$ are promised). I do agree that some programmers have an overinflated sense of intelligence and/or self-importance, though. But there are probably job types where this is much worse...

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by Aaronontheweb on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:10PM (#1535779)
Why would it be unlikely? Is it just because programmers have more college degrees than average? Isn't that more a measure of opportunity and background than it is of ability? In fact, don't you need to come from a relatively affluent background (read: can afford computers and resources needed for development) to even be exposed to programming?

I'm not trying to incite anything, but having worked in a couple of very different roles in my short career thus far, development being one of them, the proportion of mediocre programmers seems empirically equal to the proportion of medicore marketers, sales people, and so forth.

Programmers can do special things, but the mere act of programming itself doesn't make us special, better than average, or superior to anybody else. Programmer bigotry goes both ways.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by zephyrfalcon on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @02:20PM (#1536025)
"Programmers can do special things, but the mere act of programming itself doesn't make us special, better than average, or superior to anybody else."

I'm not arguing that it does, but the original statement was that the IQ distribution among programmers is no different from the general population, and I doubt that. I have of course zero proof of this, but since when has that stopped anybody? ;-)

It's just a hunch really. I associate programming with "figuring out difficult things", which is more of a pastime that (on average) more intelligent people seem to be attracted to. I am not claiming that this makes anybody "better", nor am I comparing the quality of people in different jobs, or on different educational levels. I'm solely looking at IQ (problematic as that measurement may be... but that is a different story).

To put it another way: if programmers had the same IQ distribution as the general population, then half of all programmers would have an IQ < 100. I find that VERY hard to believe. In this profession we like to joke about copy & paste programmers, or maybe PHP/Java/whatever programmers (insert favorite target here), but come on.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by orangecat on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @02:26PM (#1536047)
Why would it be unlikely?

Because programming requires a baseline of logical reasoning ability. Certainly you don't have to be a genius, but I wouldn't expect to find many with IQs below 95 or so.

the proportion of mediocre programmers seems empirically equal to the proportion of medicore marketers, sales people, and so forth.

That's true by definition. Half of all theoretical physicists are "below average", but I'd expect their average IQ to be well over 100.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by anthonyb on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @09:19PM (#1537064)
Depends on what you're measuring and the distribution of it through your population. For example, most people have greater than the average number of feet.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by narag on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @02:38PM (#1536081)
Why would it be unlikely?

My take is: because even for throwing spaghetti code you need a little more brain than average. I guess not much more, but I'd say a little more.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by wisty on Thursday July 22, 2010 @02:49AM (#1537525)
It requires the ability to write, spell, and sit for a few minutes in front of a computer screen that's not showing tweets, lolcatz, or breasts.

It also requires access to a computer, which severely underprivileged are unlikely to have.

Look at how many arts students fail the compulsorily "Intro to programming" courses that a few unis spring on them. I bet that's because (in part) they lack the logic-problem-solving (i.e. IQ) skills to cope with it.

I'd say that programmers in general have a higher general intelligence, and a much higher IQ, than the population in general.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by Retric on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @03:54PM (#1536337)
The simple reason that's not true, is the general population contains many people with IQ below 60 but you don't find them holding down jobs let alone working as programmers.

As to there being more high IQ programmers or not that's a little more complex. However, I know the HN population has an extreme oversampling of people with 160+IQ's vs. the general population.

PS: Given there are less than 700k programmers in the US you would expect less than 100 to have an IQ > 160. So, if you can locate say 200 of them you can easily settle the issue.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by aero142 on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @10:18PM (#1537156)
Here is one chart that supports that computer programmers are above average.

http://www.neatorama.com/2007/08/19/iq-distribution-of-vario...

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by hugh3 on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @10:58AM (#1535340)
What did the socially malformed do before computers were invented, anyway? (And I don't mean the Erdoses of the world, I mean the socially-malformed non-geniuses.)

Or has the invention of computers increased the number of socially malformed people out there?

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by GFischer on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @02:15PM (#1536005)
Become monks? (or other religious professions).

I can't find studies offhand, but I recall the Jesuits attracted the more intellectually minded, while the more socially outcast could try for hermits.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by philwelch on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @01:15PM (#1535803)
Read books. Tinkered with machines.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by bitwize on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @02:17PM (#1536012)
Became amateur scientists.

Sherlock Holmes is pretty archetypal of a hyper-focused Asperger's type; the recent 2009 movie with Tony Stark in it probably does a better job than most film adaptations of conveying these aspects of his character.

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by rue on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @04:46PM (#1536496)
Continuing off-topic, the ultimate Holmes was portrayed by Jeremy Brett in the several TV series based on the novels and short stories. I do not think they are well-known in the U.S. so I would recommend checking them out if interested in things holmesian.
Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by francoisdevlin on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @02:31PM (#1536059)
"recent 2009 movie with Robert Downey Jr"

Granted, I knew exactly who you meant :)

Re:Let's End Programmer Bigotry by bitwize on Wednesday July 21, 2010 @03:15PM (#1536207)
I know his real name. I was using Tony Stark as a metonym, much as Stuart Smalley is used for Al Franken. :)