News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by emodendroket on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @02:42PM (#15350941)
Without radical, NASA-style changes to typical development, where each line spends much more time being audited than being written, it is completely unreasonable to expect that kind of liability from developers.
Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by amiga-workbench on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @02:44PM (#15350969)
Ditch the dumb deadlines and the tight budgets and it would become a hell of a lot more feasible.

I WISH I had the time and budget to put due diligence into my work.

Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by emodendroket on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @02:48PM (#15351019)
You have to think about what you're building too. Feature release would come much slower than it does today. Reasonable? If you're writing software that is absolutely safety-critical, that's likely. If you're writing iTunes, well, I have my doubts.
Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by Bartweiss on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @02:57PM (#15351127)
It's not like reliable, secure software doesn't exist. It's just limited to spaces where people are willing to use years-old tech, forgo new features, and pay fortunes for auditing. Air travel, industrial machinery, medicine, and so on.

Almost like the cost-benefit actually doesn't support making the development of trivial software ten times slower and more expensive...

If there's a problem here, it's business externalities (Equifax won't pay adequately for screwing people), not engineering impossibility (the rest of us know how to patch Apache).

Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by emodendroket on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @03:01PM (#15351179)
I mostly agree, but this article cites the national 911 software, which arguably should be treated as a critical system, failing, and some medical devices whose software killed people.
Re:Programmers who want to change how we code before catastr... by Bartweiss on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @04:04PM (#15351766)
Yeah, fair enough - I've mostly been responding to too-general comments, the article is more specific.

The 911 thing seems like an obvious issue that absolutely should have been caught by a rigorous development system; it was treated like a digital phone system instead of a life-saving service. The Therac bug sort of feels like a different story, because that bug led to IEC 62304 - it's older than the practices which would now prevent it. They're both critical systems that were written without due care, though.