Re:How Big Banks Became Our Masters
by SilasX on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @02:04PM
(#15350531)
The financialization you're talking about doesn't seem bad per se; it streamlines and "purifies" the exchange you actually want to do.
For example, if I have extra money, and I know someone who could ramp up his productivity if only he could make a one-time investment (say, a cow for his farm), then I buy him a cow in return for a share of its milk. Then, to diversify, I can find thirty such people. Then I find someone who can sell the milk for a cut...[1]
Instead of all of that, we have banks, where I just give them the money, and they make the loans (and do screening, credit reporting, foreclosure, etc) and pass me a cut of the returns.
Nothing is wrong with that. The problem is when you have perverse incentives to start with (e.g. in fields like health care, or with lenders who have asymmetric information about the loans in a portfolio there's excessive trust in the vetting), where financialization just puts the same problem on steroids.
[1] Late edit: a better example of the "impure exchange" might be if I wanted to save for my retirement so I raised one more cow than I usually would with the intent to lend it out to others who are still working in return for milk, with the usual frictions like needing to convert to non-milk.
For example, if I have extra money, and I know someone who could ramp up his productivity if only he could make a one-time investment (say, a cow for his farm), then I buy him a cow in return for a share of its milk. Then, to diversify, I can find thirty such people. Then I find someone who can sell the milk for a cut...[1]
Instead of all of that, we have banks, where I just give them the money, and they make the loans (and do screening, credit reporting, foreclosure, etc) and pass me a cut of the returns.
Nothing is wrong with that. The problem is when you have perverse incentives to start with (e.g. in fields like health care, or with lenders who have asymmetric information about the loans in a portfolio there's excessive trust in the vetting), where financialization just puts the same problem on steroids.
[1] Late edit: a better example of the "impure exchange" might be if I wanted to save for my retirement so I raised one more cow than I usually would with the intent to lend it out to others who are still working in return for milk, with the usual frictions like needing to convert to non-milk.