The examples we have of countries letting their banks fail recovered¹. The onus is on anybody disagreeing to show how the US differences are relevant. Just pointing at them and screaming does not make it.
1 - AFAIK, all of them. What is interesting because it includes Brazil at the late 90's (the one single time Brazil grew in recent history).
Past experience gives us lessons for similar cases. The onus is on anybody using a model to ensure the use case is similar to the training data.
The US and Iceland are nations but it’s unreasonable to get hung up on that similarity of category. The nation is not a label for grouping economies that are comparable.
I don’t like bailouts either, for the record. My gripe is only with the scale question.
This whole size thing is a silly exercise in magical thinking anyway. Money is divisible, across all relevant scales. Pick any random nation, and its economy is larger than USA's was, some number of years ago. Would you say that we weren't exceptional back then, but we are now? When did that transition occur? What happens if some other nation's economy grows to our economy's current size, sometime in future? Will we no longer be exceptional?
But if Iceland remains its current size, neither superpower should treat it as comparable for scenario analysis.
I get a sense this is a political question for you; it’s not for me. It’s just an example.
Amazon is a company. I have a company of my own. Say my servers went down, and a few days later things were alright. Would it be Amazon Exceptionalism if they refused to learn from my experience?
Iceland and Portugal should be lessons for entities or similar size, like individual states of cities in the US.