News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Big Banks Became Our Masters by dmix on Wednesday September 27, 2017 @12:37PM (#15349536)
> My final thought is that part of the problem is the prominence of finance people in pubic decision making.

Indeed, I've read a few articles in NYTimes/WSJ now on the sale of public services in the US such as fire and water services to private equity firms. And the whole thing is told as a cautionary tale about banks and capitalism, which misses the bigger picture in how these things always start.

Typically the problems start because the government was overleveraged from taking on too much debt, typically due to poor financial management fueled by initially cheap capital from bankers operating in and out of government. Then when hard times come they continue to seek the easy answers from the bankers (instead of making hard choices like spending less) and end up selling off public resources giftwrapped in pseudo-market sounding language with very little of the actual benefits of markets: competition, private salaries, flexibility, etc.

These "banks" are famously like an octopus wrapping their tentacles around everything. We have some old effective methods for handling this type of behaviour when it's used improperly in the private sector, and there the harm is limited to a few usually wealthy parties. But it starts to get dangerous when these half-baked financial schemes that have worked in private markets get pigeonholed into government. Critical services like emergency services or drinking water are often ill-suited (and more importantly ill-prepared) to handle the potential downside.

Hopefully one day politicians will learn this lesson and learn to keep things simple in the public sector. Governments everywhere have a consistent track record of not managing money well and have a high-turnover of executives by design, so any complex financial instruments are just setting them up for failure and exploitation. Anything to do with government should be made dummy proof and straightforward. Public services should be run like public services. Mixing of private/public should be the exception, not the standard. And I say that as someone biased towards the private sector.

There are no comments on this comment yet.